Which business gains most from ABC
Four businesses are considering replacing traditional absorption costing with activity based costing (ABC).
Which business is most likely to benefit from ABC?
A A bakery that makes one type of loaf in long, continuous production runs.
B A component maker whose overheads are 6% of total cost and vary mainly with machine hours.
C A furniture maker producing 60 product lines in batches of between 5 and 5 000 units, with overheads making up 45% of total cost.
D A two-product business whose products use set-ups, inspections and machine time in the same proportions as their output.
[1]
- 1
The key. ABC adds most where overheads are a large part of cost and are caused by activities such as set-ups and orders that products use in very different amounts. Sixty product lines in batches from 5 to 5 000 units mean small batches cause far more set-ups per unit than large ones, which a single absorption rate hides. Answer C (1).
- 2
Why the others fail. A makes one product, so every overhead belongs to that product whatever method is used. B's overheads are small and volume-driven, so a machine-hour rate is already accurate enough. D's products consume every activity in the same proportion as output, so ABC would give the same cost per unit as absorption costing.
Answer
C
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: test each business against three questions: how many different products, how large are overheads, and are overheads driven by activities rather than volume? ABC is worthwhile only when all three point the same way.
Common mistake: choosing D because it already measures set-ups and inspections. Having the data is not the point: if the products use activities in the same proportions as output, ABC moves no overhead between them.