Which error a supplier's statement reveals
Each month Tanvi compares the statement of account sent by her supplier, Orchid Paper, with Orchid Paper's account in her purchases ledger.
Which error in Tanvi's books would this comparison reveal?
A An invoice from Orchid Paper for $480 was entered in the purchases journal as $840.
B A credit purchase of shelving from Orchid Paper for $600 was debited to the purchases account instead of the fixtures account.
C The total of the purchases journal was overcast by $100.
D A receipt of $350 from a customer was credited to the wrong customer's account in the sales ledger.
[1]
- 1
What the comparison checks. The supplier's statement is external evidence of what Tanvi owes Orchid Paper. It can only reveal an error that makes Orchid Paper's personal account in the purchases ledger different from the supplier's own record. In A, Orchid Paper's account is credited with $840 while the supplier's statement shows $480, so the $360 difference appears. Answer A (1).
- 2
Why the others are wrong. B is an error of principle in the nominal ledger; Orchid Paper's account is correctly credited with $600, so the statement agrees. C affects the purchases account and the purchases ledger control account, but each invoice is still posted correctly to the personal account. D is in the sales ledger and has nothing to do with a supplier.
Answer
A
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: ask which record the external document is compared with. A supplier's statement checks one personal account in the purchases ledger, so it finds errors in the amounts posted to that account, not errors in the nominal ledger or in journal totals.
Common mistake: choosing C because 'overcasting is an error that shows up'. An overcast purchases journal would make the control account disagree with the list of supplier balances, but every individual supplier's account, and so every supplier's statement, would still agree.