NPV given up for an electric fleet
Cartwell Couriers must replace its delivery vans. The directors are choosing between two fleets, each with a life of five years and no value at the end.
| Diesel fleet | Electric fleet | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost at Year 0 | 90 000 | 120 000 |
| Net cash inflow each year, Years 1–5 | 30 000 | 34 000 |
The cost of capital is 10%. Discount factors at 10%: Year 1 0.909, Year 2 0.826, Year 3 0.751, Year 4 0.683, Year 5 0.621.
The directors choose the electric fleet for environmental reasons. How much net present value do they give up by doing so?
A $10 000
B $14 840
C $30 000
D $45 160
[1]
- 1
Net present value of each fleet. The factors add to 3.790. Diesel: 30 000 × 3.790 = 113 700 − 90 000 = $23 700. Electric: 34 000 × 3.790 = 128 860 − 120 000 = $8 860. NPV given up = 23 700 − 8 860 = $14 840. Answer B (1).
- 2
Why the others fail. A uses undiscounted cash flows (diesel 150 000 − 90 000 = 60 000; electric 170 000 − 120 000 = 50 000). C compares only the costs and ignores the extra $4 000 a year the electric fleet earns. D adds the present value of the extra inflows (4 000 × 3.790 = 15 160) to the extra cost instead of setting it against it.
- 3
What the figure means. The electric fleet still has a positive NPV, so it adds value; the directors are judging that a cleaner image, lower emissions in town centres and readiness for future rules are worth about $14 840 in today's money.
Answer
B
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: when a non-financial factor leads to the option with the lower NPV, put a figure on the choice: the NPV given up is the price the business is paying for that factor, and it is a strong sentence in any advise answer.
Common mistake: choosing A. Comparing undiscounted totals ignores the time value of money, which is the whole point of NPV.