When production exceeds sales
A business makes one product. In a month it produced more units than it sold. Fixed production overhead is absorbed at the same rate per unit as in the previous month, and there were no other changes.
Which statement is correct?
A Profit under absorption costing will be higher than profit under marginal costing.
B Profit under marginal costing will be higher than profit under absorption costing.
C Both methods will report the same profit, because total fixed production overhead is the same under each method.
D Profit under absorption costing will be higher by the total fixed production overhead incurred in the month.
[1]
- 1
The key. Production above sales means inventory rises. Absorption costing carries part of this month's fixed production overhead forward in the extra units of closing inventory, whereas marginal costing charges all of it against this month's profit. So absorption costing reports the higher profit. Answer A (1).
- 2
Why the others fail. B reverses the direction: marginal costing profit is higher only when inventory falls. C ignores the timing of the charge: total fixed overhead is the same, but absorption costing does not charge all of it in this month. D overstates the gap: only the fixed overhead in the increase in inventory is carried forward, not the whole month's fixed overhead.
Answer
A
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: translate 'production exceeds sales' into 'inventory rises' before you read the options. Inventory up means absorption profit is higher; inventory down means marginal profit is higher; no change means the profits are equal.
Common mistake: choosing C because 'fixed costs are fixed'. The total does not change, but absorption costing defers some of it to the next period in closing inventory, which is exactly why the profits differ.