The ratio pattern of overtrading
The directors of four companies have described the changes in their ratios between 2025 and 2026.
Which company shows the signs of overtrading?
A Revenue up 45%; current ratio down from 1.90 : 1 to 1.10 : 1; trade payables turnover up from 38 to 71 days; the bank balance has become an overdraft.
B Revenue down 10%; current ratio up from 1.60 : 1 to 2.40 : 1; inventory turnover up from 40 to 65 days.
C Revenue up 4%; current ratio up from 3.50 : 1 to 4.20 : 1; acid test ratio up from 2.60 : 1 to 3.30 : 1.
D Revenue up 45%; current ratio up from 1.90 : 1 to 2.00 : 1; gearing up from 10% to 35% after an issue of debentures.
[1]
- 1
What overtrading looks like. A company overtrades when it expands its sales faster than its working capital can support. The pattern is rapid revenue growth together with falling liquidity, suppliers being paid more slowly and a growing reliance on the overdraft.
- 2
Apply it. Company A has all four signs: revenue up 45%, the current ratio almost halved, suppliers now waiting 71 days and the bank balance turned into an overdraft. Answer A (1).
- 3
Why the others fail. B is a business whose sales are falling and whose unsold inventory is building up, not one growing too fast. C has idle liquid assets, the opposite problem: too much working capital for its level of trade. D is growing just as fast as A, but it has financed the growth with long-term debentures, so its liquidity has held up; choosing D confuses fast growth, or higher gearing, with overtrading.
Answer
A
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: overtrading is diagnosed by ratios from two groups moving together: revenue growth (or rising ROCE) alongside falling liquidity and longer payables days. One ratio alone never proves it.
Common mistake: choosing D because revenue rose 45%. Growth funded by long-term finance is not overtrading; the test is whether the working capital can carry the extra trade.