A depreciation policy behind a misleading comparison
Rapid Ltd and Swift Ltd are delivery companies. At the start of the year each bought an identical fleet of vans for $120 000. Their revenue and all their costs other than depreciation were the same for the year.
At the end of the first year, Rapid Ltd reported a higher profit margin but a lower non-current asset turnover than Swift Ltd.
Which explains this?
A Rapid Ltd depreciates its vans by the straight-line method at 20% a year. Swift Ltd uses the reducing balance method at 40% a year.
B Rapid Ltd depreciates its vans by the reducing balance method at 40% a year. Swift Ltd uses the straight-line method at 20% a year.
C Rapid Ltd collects its trade receivables more quickly than Swift Ltd.
D Rapid Ltd has revalued its vans downwards at the end of the year.
[1]
- 1
Work out each policy for the first year. Straight-line at 20%: depreciation $24 000, carrying amount $96 000. Reducing balance at 40%: depreciation $48 000, carrying amount $72 000.
- 2
Match the two effects. The straight-line company has the lower charge, so its profit (and profit margin) is higher. It also has the higher carrying amount, so the same revenue divided by a larger figure gives a lower non-current asset turnover. Rapid Ltd must be the straight-line company. Answer A (1).
- 3
Why the others fail. B reverses the policies, the error of assuming the higher rate gives the higher profit. C affects trade receivables turnover and liquidity, not profit or the carrying amount of the vans. D lowers the carrying amount, which would raise Rapid's non-current asset turnover, and the downward revaluation would also reduce profit.
Answer
A
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: when two businesses are identical except for one accounting policy, follow the policy through both statements: the charge in the statement of profit or loss and the carrying amount in the statement of financial position. One policy choice moves several ratios at once.
Common mistake: concluding that Rapid Ltd is better managed because its profit margin is higher. The difference comes entirely from the depreciation policy, which is exactly why different accounting policies limit inter-firm comparison.