The entry for a trade-in allowance
Nadia traded in an old delivery van against a new van with a full price of $40 000. The dealer gave her a trade-in allowance of $7 500 and she paid the remaining $32 500 immediately by bank transfer.
Which double entry records the trade-in allowance?
A Debit Disposal $7 500, Credit Motor vehicles $7 500
B Debit Motor vehicles $7 500, Credit Disposal $7 500
C Debit Bank $7 500, Credit Disposal $7 500
D Debit Motor vehicles $7 500, Credit Statement of profit or loss $7 500
[1]
- 1
The allowance is the proceeds of the old van. The dealer 'pays' for the old van by reducing the price of the new one, so the allowance is credited to the disposal account in the same place as cash proceeds would be.
- 2
The allowance is also part of the cost of the new van. The new van cost $40 000: $32 500 paid by bank and $7 500 paid by handing over the old van. So the motor vehicles account is debited with $7 500 as well as with $32 500. Answer B (1).
- 3
Why the others are wrong. A reverses the entry; it has the same sides as the transfer of the old van's cost into the disposal account. C treats the allowance as money received, but no money came into the bank. D treats the allowance as a gain in itself; only the difference between the allowance and the carrying amount is a profit or loss, and that comes from balancing the disposal account.
Answer
B
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: in a part exchange the new asset is always recorded at its full price. Debit the asset account with the cash paid and with the trade-in allowance, and credit the allowance to the disposal account. Where the balance is owed to the supplier, the supplier's account is credited with the amount still owed after the allowance.
Common mistake: recording the new van at the $32 500 paid by bank. This understates the non-current asset and leaves the disposal account without any proceeds, so the loss on disposal is overstated.