The view asserts that governments should treat economic growth as the single most important macroeconomic objective, above price stability, full employment and the balanced distribution of income. The view has strong support but is overstated when the environmental and distributional costs of growth are weighed, and the answer depends on the economy's starting position.
Case supporting the view. Economic growth is the mechanism that raises real GDP per capita, lowers unemployment and raises tax revenue. Each of these outcomes is itself a macroeconomic objective, so prioritising growth tends to deliver several objectives at once. Growth also provides the fiscal resources to fund every other policy — healthcare, education, redistribution, environmental spending — without raising tax rates, which makes it almost a precondition for everything else a government might want to do. In economies with high absolute poverty, the welfare gain from each extra percentage point of growth is very large: more food, more housing, lower infant mortality, longer life expectancy. For such economies, prioritising growth is close to prioritising welfare directly.
Case against / qualifications. Economic growth imposes costs that policymakers cannot ignore. Rising output generally brings higher carbon emissions, pollution and resource depletion, costs that are external to GDP but reduce long-run welfare. Growth tends to widen income inequality because the gains flow disproportionately to workers in growing sectors and to owners of capital; without redistribution, the median household may gain much less than the headline figure suggests. Rapid growth risks inflationary pressure as the economy approaches full capacity, so pursuing growth above price stability can produce costly inflation that erodes real incomes. Finally, GDP itself does not measure well-being: leisure, work-life balance and household production are not in the national accounts, so a growth-above-all approach can prioritise the measured number over the thing it is supposed to proxy.
Qualifying mechanisms. Three features of the economy determine whether 'prioritise growth' is the right answer. (i) Starting living-standard. In a low-income economy, the welfare gain from an extra percentage point is very large, so prioritising growth is almost always correct; in a high-income economy, additional output buys relatively little extra well-being and the environmental and distributional costs weigh more heavily. (ii) Composition of growth. Growth concentrated in resource-light services and clean technology imposes far smaller costs than growth in extractive, energy-intensive sectors, so the sectoral mix matters as much as the rate. (iii) Distribution. Broad-based growth that lifts median wages produces a far better match between GDP growth and welfare growth than growth captured by a narrow group of asset-owners.
Reasoned judgement. The view that governments should prioritise economic growth is right in direction, overstated as 'above all'. Growth is the engine that raises living standards and funds every other objective, and in low-income economies with high absolute poverty it is the dominant priority. In high-income economies, prioritising growth above price stability, employment and environmental protection is harder to defend: the welfare gain per extra per cent of growth is smaller and the costs weigh more heavily. The sharper formulation is that governments should prioritise broad-based, resource-light growth that advances other objectives rather than conflicting with them, and treat 'growth above all' as a slogan that fits some economies better than others. On balance, prioritising growth is the right default for an economy below its material welfare peak; above that peak, the trade-offs become real and 'above all' is too strong.