A government in principle pursues all three AS-level macroeconomic objectives — price stability, low unemployment and economic growth — but it must set a priority when its attention and policy space are limited. The three candidates each have a serious claim.
Case for price stability as top priority. The modern macroeconomic consensus places price stability first, which is reflected in the way most central banks around the world are given an inflation-targeting mandate (typically around 2%) with operational independence. The reasoning is twofold. First, without stable, predictable prices, long-term planning collapses: savings are eroded, mortgages become risky, long-horizon investment projects face a risk premium, and international competitiveness is lost if inflation exceeds trading partners'. Second, price stability is a PRE-CONDITION for the other objectives: high inflation damages growth by discouraging investment and eroding real incomes, while deflation damages employment by causing deferred spending and debt deflation. On this reading, achieving price stability lays the foundation for the other objectives, so it has to come first.
Case for low unemployment as top priority. The social and personal costs of unemployment are concentrated and severe. An unemployed worker loses income, loses skills over time (hysteresis), suffers worse physical and mental health, and faces a higher probability of family breakdown; communities with persistently high unemployment show higher crime rates and lower social mobility. By contrast, the costs of moderate inflation are small, diffuse and reversible. For a government whose primary responsibility is the welfare of its citizens, keeping unemployment low has first-order welfare benefits. The achievement of low unemployment also tends to deliver growth almost mechanically (fuller use of resources moves output towards potential) and the resulting tax revenues improve public finances without raising rates.
Case for economic growth as top priority. Over the long run, the material standard of living depends on real GDP per head, and only sustained economic growth raises this. Price stability can be achieved inside a stagnant economy (Japan in the 1990s is the textbook example — stable prices, chronic stagnation), and low unemployment can be achieved at low real wages. Only growth lifts living standards durably, finances pensions and public services, and allows poverty reduction without redistribution alone. For developing economies in particular, growth is the mechanism that lifts tens of millions out of poverty — and it is also what GENERATES the resources with which the government can pursue the other two objectives later.
Reasoned judgement. The right top priority depends on the state of the economy. In a stable, developed economy near full employment, price stability is the natural top priority — which is why central banks in such economies are given an inflation-target mandate as their primary (sometimes sole) legal objective. In a developing economy with low real incomes and high poverty, sustained economic growth is the sensible top priority because it is the mechanism that raises living standards. In the middle of a severe recession or crisis, supporting employment and output has to come first, with inflation targeting temporarily relaxed. The strongest statement of the answer is therefore conditional: no single objective is the top priority in all circumstances — the ranking depends on where the economy sits and what shock, if any, it is responding to. In the standard case of a developed economy in normal times, however, the modern consensus favours price stability as the primary objective, with the other two pursued by the appropriate separate instruments (fiscal and supply-side policy).