An appreciation of a floating exchange rate makes the domestic currency stronger against foreign currencies: one unit of the currency now buys more foreign currency. Whether this ALWAYS harms the domestic economy, as the claim states, requires setting out the mechanisms on both sides.
Case for the view — appreciation harms the economy. An appreciation makes exports priced in domestic currency MORE expensive in foreign currency, so foreign demand for the country's exports falls. It makes imports priced in foreign currency CHEAPER in domestic currency, so domestic demand switches away from domestic substitutes to imports. Net exports (X−M) FALL, and AD=C+I+G+(X−M) shifts LEFT (AD1→AD2). Along an upward-sloping SRAS, equilibrium national income falls from (P1,Y1) to (P2,Y2): real output falls, firms facing weaker demand reduce hiring, and cyclical unemployment rises. Export-intensive sectors (manufacturing, tourism) are hit hardest; the headline growth rate suffers. On this standard reading, the appreciation is a clearly contractionary macro shock, with falling real GDP and falling employment.
Case against the view — appreciation can benefit certain economies. The same appreciation delivers three potentially beneficial channels. First, it LOWERS the domestic-currency price of imported finished goods and inputs — a direct anti-inflationary effect. For an economy whose main macro problem is inflation above target (perhaps because of imported energy or food shocks), an appreciation is a useful disinflationary tool: the price level falls both from the leftward AD shift AND from cheaper imported prices. Second, cheaper imports raise the REAL PURCHASING POWER of households — a given money income now buys more foreign-produced goods, so the standard of living in real terms rises. Third, cheaper imported capital goods and intermediate inputs REDUCE the domestic-currency cost of productive investment, supporting investment in the capital stock and, over time, raising LRAS — a longer-run growth benefit that cuts against the headline short-run output loss.
Reasoned judgement. The 'always' in the claim is the pivot. An appreciation IS likely to harm an economy that is already running below potential (where it does not need further AD contraction) and whose exports are a large share of GDP (where the trade-channel loss is big). It is likely to BENEFIT an economy that is already overheating with high imported inflation (where disinflation is welcome) or that imports its capital goods and benefits from cheaper investment. The claim 'appreciation ALWAYS harms a domestic economy' is therefore too strong. The strongest formulation is: in the standard case of an economy near or below potential with large export sectors and anchored inflation, an appreciation is net harmful through the real-output and employment channels; in the specific case of an overheating economy with high imported inflation, an appreciation can be net beneficial as a disinflationary tool and a boost to real household purchasing power. Policy-makers in open economies have historically treated moderate appreciation as a useful inflation-fighting tool, which is itself evidence that the 'always harmful' claim does not hold universally.