Case for the view. Economic theory defines rational decision-making as maximising net benefit, where benefit is weighed against cost. In a world of scarce resources, the correct measure of cost is opportunity cost — the value of the next-best alternative foregone — because this is what the agent actually sacrifices by choosing. An agent who ignores opportunity cost and uses only accounting cost (money paid) will under-value the sacrifice and make allocatively inefficient choices: a firm that occupies its own owned factory 'for free' ignores the rent it could have earned by leasing it, over-produces in that factory and mis-reads its true profitability. By making opportunity cost explicit, the agent compares like with like — the full value of the sacrificed alternative against the full value of the chosen one.
Case against the view — other considerations matter. First, risk and uncertainty: the value of the foregone alternative is often an estimate, not a certainty. A rational agent must adjust for the probability distribution of outcomes, not just the headline opportunity cost. Second, time horizon: an opportunity cost that is low in the short run may be high in the long run (a government spending reserves today foregoes future flexibility), so a single-period opportunity cost under-states the decision's true cost. Third, equity and distribution: two alternatives with identical opportunity cost can produce very different distributions of gains and losses across groups; a rational decision-maker with equity in their objective function must weight these, not just the sacrifice. Fourth, information: the agent may not know every alternative, so the 'opportunity cost' they compute is an upper-bound estimate — other decision tools (sensitivity analysis, scenario planning) are needed alongside.
Reasoned judgement. Opportunity cost is the correct cost concept in rational decision-making — ignoring it leads to systematic over-use of 'free' resources. But 'most important consideration' goes further than that. In a certain, single-period, equity-neutral decision between well-understood alternatives, opportunity cost IS the dominant consideration — the agent should simply pick the option whose benefits exceed its opportunity cost by the widest margin. In a decision characterised by material risk, long time horizons, distributional stakes or information gaps, opportunity cost remains necessary but is no longer sufficient: rational agents must weight it against expected risk-adjusted benefits and distributional outcomes. On balance, the view is correct when framed as 'the correct cost concept to use' but overstated when framed as 'the only or dominant consideration'. The strongest formulation is: opportunity cost is the right measure of what is sacrificed; whether it is the most important consideration depends on the risk profile and equity stakes of the decision at hand.