Case supporting the claim. A market economy answers the three allocation questions through prices and the profit motive. For what to produce, prices transmit consumer preferences to producers: profitable goods are produced in larger quantities, loss-making goods disappear, so output matches what consumers actually want. For how to produce, competition compels firms to minimise unit cost by choosing the least-cost input mix, raising productive efficiency; the profit incentive rewards innovation, so dynamic efficiency rises over time. Decisions are decentralised to millions of informed agents — Hayek's point that the knowledge of time, place and preference is dispersed and cannot be centrally aggregated. The twentieth-century experience of planned economies — persistent shortages (illustrated by multi-year queues for cars and housing), low productivity growth and poor-quality consumer goods — is consistent with this diagnosis.
Case against the claim / in favour of planned systems. The market mechanism answers for whom to produce according to the distribution of purchasing power. Where income and wealth are highly unequal, this produces outcomes many societies regard as unacceptable: luxury consumption for a few alongside basic unmet needs for others. A pure market also under-produces goods whose benefits are non-excludable (basic research, national defence) and whose private returns do not capture full social value, because the profit motive does not reward their supply. Markets exhibit cyclical unemployment and macroeconomic volatility, which a planning authority can — in principle — smooth. A planned economy can prioritise equity, universal provision of basic services (education, healthcare), full employment, and long-horizon strategic investment (infrastructure, climate transition) that market participants discount or ignore. In this sense a planned system can answer certain allocation questions — particularly 'for whom' and 'what public and merit goods' — more effectively than a pure market.
Reasoned judgement. The claim 'markets are more effective' holds strongly for most private goods, where consumers are reasonably informed, externalities are small, and distribution according to income is socially acceptable. It holds less strongly, and sometimes fails, for public goods, merit goods, goods with large externalities, and the distribution of output across society. The empirical corollary is important: almost no modern economy relies purely on either mechanism. The high-income economies that performed best over the twentieth century combined market allocation of private goods with state provision of public goods, redistribution for equity, and regulation for externalities. The strongest formulation of the view is therefore that markets are more effective at allocating resources within the domain where their assumptions hold, and planned mechanisms are more effective where market assumptions fail. The practical answer in nearly every real-world context is a mixed economy, and the policy question is not which pure system wins but where the boundary should be drawn between market and state.