Economic growth has two components — actual growth (year-on-year change in real GDP) and potential growth (growth in LRAS). Demand-side and supply-side policies work on these two components differently, which means their effectiveness depends on the kind of growth needed and the state the economy is in.
Demand-side policies. Expansionary fiscal policy (higher government spending G, lower direct and indirect taxation) and expansionary monetary policy (lower policy interest rates, quantitative easing) raise aggregate demand. If the economy is below potential — a negative output gap, as in a recession — AD rises along a relatively flat section of SRAS: real GDP rises, unemployment falls, and the economy returns towards Yf. In this situation, demand-side policy is highly effective at raising actual growth. Automatic stabilisers do some of this work in real time, and discretionary expansionary policy closes the remaining gap.
Limits of demand-side policies. Three limits bite as the economy approaches Yf. First, capacity: once AD crosses LRAS, additional AD produces inflation, not growth — the inflationary consequence of trying to grow past potential. Second, lags: fiscal policy has a decision lag (budget cycles), a legislative lag and an implementation lag; monetary policy has a transmission lag of 12-18 months. Third, crowding out: deficit-financed stimulus can raise interest rates and crowd out private investment, which is a long-run cost. Demand-side policy cannot raise potential output and so cannot generate sustained real-GDP growth beyond Yf.
Supply-side policies. Supply-side policies shift LRAS rightward and so raise potential output. Investment in human capital (education, vocational training, public health), investment in physical capital and infrastructure (roads, ports, power, digital), investment in R&D and technology, and institutional reforms (competition policy, labour-market reform, lower regulatory burdens, tax reform) each raise productive capacity. On the AD/AS diagram, LRAS shifts from LRAS1 to LRAS2, so the economy can sustainably produce more real output at a lower long-run price level. Supply-side policy therefore generates sustained real-GDP growth without the capacity constraint.
Limits of supply-side policies. The main limits are three. First, time lags: education and R&D take years, sometimes decades, to deliver, so supply-side policy cannot close a short-run negative output gap. Second, uncertainty of magnitude: the government does not know how large the LRAS shift will be, and some reforms (particularly labour-market deregulation) may deliver smaller effects than claimed. Third, distributional and fiscal cost: human-capital and R&D policies are fiscally costly, and some deregulation policies (lower minimum wage, weaker union rights) raise growth at the cost of widening inequality, which weakens their inclusive-growth credentials.
Interaction between the two. Supply-side policy raises Yf, but if AD does not grow to meet the new capacity, the extra potential sits idle and a negative output gap persists — growth is possible but not actual. Demand-side policy raises AD, but if LRAS does not shift, growth is temporary and comes at the cost of inflation. The two sides are therefore complements, not substitutes: effective growth policy raises capacity and ensures demand grows to use it.
Reasoned judgement. The effective mix depends on three conditions. (i) State of the cycle. If the economy is in a negative output gap, demand-side policy is more effective in the short run — it closes the gap directly, and automatic stabilisers already push in that direction. If the economy is already near Yf, demand-side policy is largely inflationary and supply-side policy is the only route to further sustained growth. (ii) Time horizon. Short-run growth is mostly demand-side; long-run growth is almost entirely supply-side, because LRAS is what sets the sustainable level of real GDP. (iii) Fiscal position and debt sustainability. When public debt is high, the crowding-out and refinancing costs of deficit-financed stimulus rise, constraining the demand-side option; supply-side investment in productivity (education, R&D) is defensible even in that case because it raises future tax capacity. On balance, the most effective policy framework sequences the two: use demand-side policy to close short-run output gaps and keep inflation on target, and use supply-side policy to raise Yf steadily so that the economy's long-run growth rate is as high as possible. Neither on its own is sufficient; the view that one 'is more effective' than the other is best read as 'more effective for a given purpose and horizon'.