Both raising taxes and cutting government spending reduce a budget deficit, but they do so with different consequences for aggregate demand, growth, equity and the long-run supply side. Whether raising taxes is preferable depends on how the two are designed and on the state of the economy at the time.
Case for raising taxes. A tax rise delivers an immediate revenue response: income tax or corporation tax feed directly into the government's revenue line in the next fiscal year. Importantly, it preserves the government's spending programmes — the roads, schools, hospitals and benefits that justify public spending in the first place (LO 5.2.5). This matters especially for capital spending on infrastructure, which raises the economy's long-run productive capacity; cutting it to balance the budget today harms growth tomorrow. A tax rise can also be designed to be progressive — raising the income-tax rate on higher bands, or raising corporation tax rather than VAT — so that the burden sits on those most able to pay. Equity (one of the 5.2.4 reasons for taxation) is therefore better protected under a tax-based consolidation.
Case for cutting spending instead. Tax rises carry two problems. First, they reduce households' disposable income, so consumption C falls and AD leftwards — a contractionary effect that can be large if the MPC is high. Second, they weaken incentives: a higher MRT on labour income can discourage additional work, and a higher corporation tax may discourage investment. Spending cuts, by contrast, can be designed to remove inefficient programmes (duplicated agencies, poorly targeted subsidies) that produce little social value, improving the efficiency of the public sector while reducing the deficit. In political-economy terms, a government that cuts spending signals discipline to creditors and markets, which can reduce the interest rate it pays on new borrowing — compounding the deficit reduction over time.
Composition matters more than the choice between them. The two instruments are not single levers. On the tax side, a rise in a progressive income tax is very different from a rise in VAT on necessities, which is regressive and hurts the poorest hardest. On the spending side, a cut in current spending on waste is very different from a cut in capital spending on infrastructure, which damages long-run growth. The best programme typically combines a progressive tax rise with a cut in inefficient current spending while protecting capital investment.
Timing matters too. Both instruments reduce AD, so each is contractionary in the short run. Carried out during a recession (as in Country Z above), either choice risks deepening the downturn — a point reinforced by the AD/AS analysis of 5.2.7. The responsible sequencing in that case is to postpone most of the consolidation until recovery is secure and to use the strongest possible automatic revenue response rather than discretionary tightening.
Reasoned judgement. Raising taxes is preferable to cutting spending when (i) the alternative is to cut capital spending that would raise long-run productive capacity, (ii) the tax rise can be designed progressively so that it protects equity, and (iii) the composition of government spending is already efficient so there is little waste to cut. Cutting spending is preferable when (i) the current spending in question is wasteful or poorly targeted, (ii) a tax rise would damage the labour-supply or investment response, and (iii) credibility with creditors or markets is at a premium. In most real economies the right answer is a combination — a progressive tax rise alongside a cut in inefficient current spending, protecting capital spending throughout, and sequenced so that heavy consolidation is avoided while unemployment is still high. On balance, raising (progressive) taxes is preferable to cutting (capital) spending; cutting (wasteful current) spending is preferable to raising (regressive indirect) taxes. The 'which is better' answer therefore depends on which tax rises and which spending cuts are on the table.