de Broglie wavelengths of an electron and a proton at the same speed
An electron and a proton are moving with the same speed.
Which of the following statements about their de Broglie wavelengths is correct?
A The electron and the proton have the same de Broglie wavelength.
B The de Broglie wavelength of the electron is about 43 times that of the proton.
C The de Broglie wavelength of the electron is about 1800 times that of the proton.
D The de Broglie wavelength of the proton is about 1800 times that of the electron.
(1)
- 1
. With the same , , so the lighter electron has the longer wavelength by the mass ratio . C (1)
- 2
Distractors. A ignores the mass in : equal speeds do not give equal momenta. B is the ratio , which applies when the two particles have the same kinetic energy, not the same speed. D has the ratio the wrong way round: the heavier proton has the larger momentum and so the shorter wavelength.
Answer
C
Examiner tip
Decide first what is the same for the two particles. Same speed gives ; same kinetic energy gives , which is the trap in option B. A quick check: the larger momentum always goes with the shorter wavelength.