Extension of a longer, thicker wire
Two wires, P and Q, are made of the same steel. Wire Q is twice as long as wire P and has twice the diameter of wire P. Each wire supports a hanging lamp of the same weight, and both wires obey Hooke's law.
The extension of wire P is .
Which of the following is the extension of wire Q?
A
B
C
D
(1)
- 1
Combine stress , strain and stress/strain to get . The force and the Young modulus are the same for both wires. Doubling the original length doubles . Doubling the diameter makes the cross-sectional area four times larger, which divides by 4. Overall , so the answer is B (1)
- 2
Why the other options are wrong. A allows for the area being four times larger but forgets that a wire twice as long extends twice as much. C treats the area as proportional to the diameter (×2), so the two changes appear to cancel. D allows for the longer length only and ignores the larger cross-sectional area.
Answer
B ()
Examiner tip
Write the combined relationship before thinking about ratios; candidates who reason in words usually lose one of the two factors. The most common slip is option C: area depends on diameter squared, so doubling quadruples . The Young modulus is a property of the material, so it is the same for both wires.