Which nuclear change releases energy
The binding energy per nucleon of nuclei rises to a maximum for nucleon numbers close to 56 and then decreases slowly for larger nucleon numbers.
Which of the following nuclear changes would release energy?
A two iron-56 nuclei fusing to form a nucleus with nucleon number 112
B an iron-56 nucleus splitting into two silicon-28 nuclei
C two lithium-6 nuclei fusing to form a carbon-12 nucleus
D a helium-4 nucleus splitting into two hydrogen-2 nuclei
(1)
- 1
Energy is released only when the products have a greater total binding energy than the starting nuclei, i.e. when the change moves the nucleons towards the peak of the curve near . Fusing two lithium-6 nuclei ( MeV per nucleon) into carbon-12 ( MeV per nucleon) increases the binding energy per nucleon, so about 28 MeV is released. C (1)
- 2
Distractors. A moves from the peak to the right (heavier than iron), so the binding energy per nucleon falls and energy must be supplied. B moves from the peak to the left (lighter than iron): again the binding energy per nucleon falls. D splits one of the most tightly bound light nuclei ( MeV per nucleon) into hydrogen-2 ( MeV per nucleon), which needs a large energy input.
Answer
C
Examiner tip
Candidates who learn 'fusion releases energy and fission releases energy' as a slogan choose A or B. Whether a change releases energy depends on which side of the peak it starts and where it ends: fusion releases energy only for light nuclei and fission only for heavy nuclei, because both must move towards iron-56.