Which resultant of two displacements is impossible
A hiker walks a displacement of 3.0 km and then a second displacement of 4.0 km. The two displacements can be in any directions on level ground.
Which of the following cannot be the magnitude of the hiker's resultant displacement?
A 1.0 km
B 5.0 km
C 7.0 km
D 8.0 km
(1)
- 1
The magnitude of the resultant of two vectors lies between their difference (vectors in opposite directions) and their sum (vectors in the same direction): . 8.0 km is larger than the sum, so it is impossible. D (1)
- 2
Distractors. A is possible: the hiker walks 3.0 km and then 4.0 km in the opposite direction, giving km. B is possible: the displacements are at right angles, giving km. C is possible: both displacements are in the same direction, giving km.
Answer
D (8.0 km is greater than the sum of the two magnitudes).
Examiner tip
Candidates who reach for Pythagoras every time pick B as 'the' answer without reading the word cannot. Displacements are vectors, so the angle between them matters: the resultant can be anything from the difference to the sum of the magnitudes, but never outside that range.