Choosing the largest particle from a set of Period 3 ions
Which ion has the largest radius?
A Na⁺
B Mg²⁺
C Cl⁻
D S²⁻
[1 mark]
- 1
Na⁺ and Mg²⁺ have lost their third shell (configuration 2,8), so they are much smaller than the anions, which keep three occupied shells (2,8,8). That removes A and B. Cl⁻ and S²⁻ both have 18 electrons, but S²⁻ has only 16 protons compared with 17 in Cl⁻, so its electrons are held less tightly and the ion is larger. ✓ 1 mark — D
Answer
D (S²⁻)
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: First sort the ions by number of occupied shells, then compare nuclear charge within an isoelectronic set.
Most common mistake: Choosing C because chlorine is 'further along the period' — for isoelectronic anions, the one with fewer protons is larger.