Which two species have identical chemical properties?
Which pair of species have identical chemical properties?
A and
B and
C and
D and
[1 mark]
- 1
Chemical properties depend on the number and arrangement of electrons, which is fixed by the proton number for a neutral atom. A is an atom and an ion (17 and 18 electrons), so their chemistry differs. C are different elements (19 and 20 protons). D have the same number of electrons (10) but different nuclear charges, and one is an ion, so they are different species with different chemistry. B are neutral atoms of the same element — isotopes — with 6 electrons arranged in both. ✓ 1 mark — B
Answer
B
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: 'Identical chemical properties' needs the same element and the same charge — i.e. isotopes of a neutral atom (or the same ion).
Most common mistake: Choosing A because both are chlorine. Adding an electron changes the chemistry completely: Cl atoms are oxidising, Cl⁻ ions are not.