Which species can act as both acid and base?
Which species can behave as both a Brønsted–Lowry acid and a Brønsted–Lowry base?
A NH₄⁺
B HSO₄⁻
C Cl⁻
D Na⁺
[1 mark]
- 1
To act as an acid a species must have an H⁺ it can donate; to act as a base it must be able to accept an H⁺ (it needs a lone pair). NH₄⁺ can donate H⁺ (→ NH₃) but has no lone pair to accept another. Cl⁻ can accept H⁺ but has no H⁺ to donate. Na⁺ can do neither. HSO₄⁻ can donate H⁺ (→ SO₄²⁻) and accept H⁺ (→ H₂SO₄). ✓ 1 mark — B
Answer
B HSO₄⁻ — it can lose H⁺ to form SO₄²⁻ or gain H⁺ to form H₂SO₄.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: Test each option twice — 'does it have an H⁺ to give?' and 'can it take one?' Only species that pass both tests are amphoteric (water, HSO₄⁻, HCO₃⁻).
Most common mistake: Choosing A because NH₄⁺ contains hydrogen and appears in acid–base equations; it is only ever an acid.