Which species has the same shape as BF₃?
Which species has the same shape as a boron trifluoride molecule, BF₃?
A NH₃
B AlCl₃ (gaseous monomer)
C BF₄⁻
D PH₃
[1 mark]
- 1
BF₃ has three bonding pairs and no lone pair on boron, so it is trigonal planar (120°). Look for another species with 3 bonding pairs and 0 lone pairs on the central atom.
- 2
NH₃ and PH₃ each have 3 bonding pairs plus one lone pair (pyramidal). BF₄⁻ has 4 bonding pairs (tetrahedral). Aluminium is in the same group as boron: in AlCl₃, Al uses all three outer electrons to form three bonds and has no lone pair, so it is trigonal planar. ✓ 1 mark — B
Answer
B
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: Classify every option by (bonding pairs, lone pairs) before thinking about shape names — the shape follows directly from those two numbers.
Most common mistake: Choosing A or D because the formula looks like 'XY₃'. Same formula type does not mean same shape; the lone pair on N or P makes those molecules pyramidal.