Identifying the reagent giving only gaseous by-products
Carboxylic acids can be converted into acyl chlorides using PCl₃ (with heating), PCl₅, or SOCl₂.
Identify which of these three reagents gives by-products that are BOTH gases at room temperature, leaving the acyl chloride with nothing to separate out.
[1 mark]
- 1
SOCl₂ reacts with a carboxylic acid to give the acyl chloride plus sulfur dioxide and hydrogen chloride, both of which escape as gases; PCl₃ gives H₃PO₃ and PCl₅ gives liquid POCl₃ alongside HCl gas, so both of those leave a by-product that must be separated. ✓ 1 mark — SOCl₂
Answer
SOCl₂ — the by-products SO₂ and HCl are both gases.
Examiner tip
Examiner tip: Learn this as the reason SOCl₂ is the 'cleanest' route to an acyl chloride — no by-product needs to be filtered or distilled off.
Most common mistake: Choosing PCl₅ because 'it only gives two by-products' — POCl₃ is a liquid, not a gas.