Metal or non-metal? Classifying elements from data
The table gives some properties of four elements.
| element | melting point / °C | electrical conductivity when solid | effect of hammering |
|---|---|---|---|
| P | 1085 | good | flattens |
| Q | 113 | poor | shatters |
| R | about 3600 | good | shatters |
| S | 660 | good | flattens |
(a) Which two elements are metals? Give two reasons.
(b) Element R conducts electricity but is a non-metal. Use the table to explain why it is not classed as a metal.
(c) State two other physical properties that are typical of metals.
- 1
(a) P and S: they conduct electricity when solid and they are malleable (they flatten instead of shattering). Their melting points are also fairly high.
- 2
(b) R is brittle — it shatters when hammered — so it is not malleable. (R behaves like graphite, a form of carbon: a non-metal that conducts.)
- 3
(c) Any two: good thermal conductors; ductile (can be drawn into wires); high boiling points; high density; shiny when freshly cut.
Answer
(a) P and S — they conduct electricity and are malleable (b) it is brittle / shatters, so not malleable (c) e.g. good thermal conductors; ductile
Examiner tip
Do not rely on one property. Electrical conductivity alone would wrongly class R as a metal, and a high melting point alone is shared by many non-metals such as carbon. A common error in (c) is to repeat a property already given in the table — the question asks for other properties.