Season-ticket holders: census, sampling unit and sampling frame
A regional bus company keeps a database of the names and addresses of all holders of its annual season ticket. The company wants to find out what its season-ticket holders think of a proposed change to the timetable.
(a) Give one advantage and one disadvantage, in context, of the company taking a census of its season-ticket holders. (2)
(b) Identify a suitable sampling unit. (1)
The company later wants to find out the views of everyone who travels on its buses. It plans to use the same database as the sampling frame.
(c) Explain why the database is not a suitable sampling frame for this purpose. (1)
- 1
(a) Advantage: a census asks every season-ticket holder, so the result gives the views of the whole population and there is no sampling variation. B1
- 2
Disadvantage: contacting all holders and processing their replies would take a long time and cost a lot. B1
- 3
(b) The sampling unit is a single member of the population, here one season-ticket holder. B1
- 4
(c) The new population is every passenger, but the database lists only season-ticket holders. Passengers who pay for single or day tickets are not on it, so they could never be chosen and the sample would not represent all passengers. B1
Answer
(a) Advantage: every holder's view is included, so the result is exact for the population. Disadvantage: time-consuming and expensive with holders. (b) A season-ticket holder. (c) The database omits passengers who do not hold a season ticket, so they cannot be selected.
Examiner tip
In (a) an advantage written as "it is accurate" with no reference to the whole population, or a disadvantage written only as "it is hard", is too vague for the B1. Tie each answer to the holders. In (b) the sampling unit is one individual, not "the database" and not "the sample". In (c) the mark needs the reason: name the people who are missing from the list.