Fillings after a fluoride varnish programme
Records at a dental clinic show that, in past years, of children attending a check-up needed a filling. The clinic then ran a programme of fluoride varnish treatments. A random sample of children attending a check-up after the programme is taken, and of them need a filling.
Test, at the level of significance, whether or not there is evidence that the proportion of children needing a filling has decreased. State your hypotheses clearly. (4)
- 1
Let be the proportion of children who need a filling. The question asks about a decrease, so the test is one-tailed, in the lower tail. B1
- 2
Under the number in the sample needing a filling is , which is tabulated. Find the probability of a result at least as extreme as the one observed, . B1
- 3
Compare with the significance level. The probability is below , so the result is significant and is rejected. dM1
- 4
Conclusion in context: there is evidence that the proportion of children needing a filling has decreased since the fluoride programme. A1 cso
Answer
, . , so reject : there is evidence that the proportion of children needing a filling has decreased.
Examiner tip
The hypotheses must be written in terms of the parameter ; statements such as score B0. The probability needed is , the chance of a result this extreme, not . The critical-region route earns the same marks: and give , and lies in it. The final A1 needs a conclusion about the proportion of children needing a filling, and it is lost by a claim that the programme has been proved to work.