Putting a canteen's modelling actions in order
The manager of a school canteen wants to know how many vegetarian meals to prepare each day. She carries out the following actions, listed here in a random order.
- A She records the number of vegetarian meals chosen on each school day for the next four weeks.
- B She proposes a statistical model for the number of vegetarian meals chosen on a school day.
- C She compares the numbers recorded in A with the numbers predicted in E.
- D She decides that she needs to predict the daily demand for vegetarian meals so that she rarely runs out.
- E She uses the model to predict, for each of the next four weeks, how many days will need more than vegetarian meals.
(a) Write the letters to in the order in which they should be carried out in the modelling process. (2)
The predictions agree well with the recorded numbers on every day of the week except Fridays, when many more vegetarian meals are chosen than the model predicts.
(b) Describe what the manager should do next. (1)
- 1
(a) The cycle starts from the real-world problem (D) and then sets up a model of it (B). Getting these first two in the right order earns the first mark. B1
- 2
Next the model is used to make predictions (E); data are then collected (A); finally the predictions are compared with the data (C). The full order is: B1
- 3
(b) The comparison shows a systematic failure on one day, so the model must be refined (for example, a separate model for Fridays, when demand is higher), and the cycle repeated: new predictions, new data, a new comparison. B1
Answer
(a) (b) Refine the model so that it allows for higher demand on Fridays (for example a separate model for Fridays), then make new predictions and compare them with new data.
Examiner tip
The most common slip is putting the data collection (A) before the predictions (E): the data used to test a model are collected after the model has made its predictions, otherwise the comparison proves nothing. In (b) 'the model is wrong' or 'start again' does not score; the answer must say the model is refined and that the predict–compare stages are repeated, and a good answer says how the refinement deals with Fridays.