Choosing the temperatures for a beetroot permeability test
A student planned to investigate the effect of temperature on the permeability of beetroot cell membranes (Core Practical 3). She planned to place one beetroot cylinder in 10 cm³ of distilled water in a water bath at each of three temperatures, 20 °C, 40 °C and 60 °C, for 30 minutes, and then to measure the absorbance of the water with a colorimeter.
(a) Comment on the number and range of temperatures in this plan. (2)
(b) Suggest why the student should set up more than one beetroot cylinder at each temperature. (1)
- 1
(a) Number: three temperatures are too few to show the shape of the relationship. Membrane leakage often rises sharply over a narrow band of temperatures, and with readings only at 40 °C and 60 °C the student cannot tell where between them the rise begins (1).
- 2
(a) Range: the range should be wider and the interval smaller, for example at least five temperatures from 10 °C to 70 °C at 10 °C intervals (1).
- 3
(b) With repeats (for example three cylinders at each temperature) the student can identify anomalous readings and calculate a mean, so the results are more repeatable (1).
Answer
(a) Three temperatures are too few to show the pattern or to locate where leakage starts to rise sharply; use at least five temperatures over a wider range, e.g. 10–70 °C at 10 °C intervals. (b) So anomalous readings can be identified and a mean calculated.
Examiner tip
'Comment on' needs a judgement with a reason: 'more temperatures' alone is not enough, so say what the extra readings would show (where the leakage begins to increase). In (b), 'to make it reliable' is too vague on its own; name what repeats allow you to do: spot anomalies and calculate a mean.