Chromosomes and chromatids in an onion root tip cell
Onion root tip cells have a diploid number of 16 chromosomes (2n = 16).
(a) Which row shows the number of chromosomes and the number of chromatids in one onion root tip cell at metaphase of mitosis?
| Number of chromosomes | Number of chromatids | |
|---|---|---|
| A | 8 | 8 |
| B | 16 | 16 |
| C | 16 | 32 |
| D | 32 | 32 |
(1)
(b) State the number of chromosomes in each daughter cell produced when this cell divides by mitosis. (1)
(c) Give one reason why it is important that root tip cells divide by mitosis and not by meiosis. (1)
- 1
(a) DNA was replicated in the S phase, so at metaphase each of the 16 chromosomes is made of two sister chromatids joined at the centromere: 16 chromosomes, 32 chromatids. C (1)
- 2
(a) distractors. A is the number in a haploid cell after meiosis, not a diploid cell in mitosis. B ignores replication: it describes the cell in G1, when each chromosome is one chromatid. D is the count after the centromeres divide in anaphase, when each separated chromatid counts as a chromosome, so it does not fit metaphase.
- 3
(b) Mitosis keeps the chromosome number: each daughter cell has 16 chromosomes (1).
- 4
(c) Daughter cells must keep the diploid number / be genetically identical to the parent cell, so that the new cells of the growing root carry the same genetic information; meiosis would halve the chromosome number and produce genetically different cells (1).
Answer
(a) C (b) 16 (c) Mitosis keeps the diploid number and gives genetically identical cells for growth; meiosis would halve the number and produce variation.
Examiner tip
Count chromatids only after asking whether the S phase has happened: from S to metaphase every chromosome has two chromatids. In (c), 'mitosis makes identical cells' alone is a restatement; tie it to growth and to the diploid number being kept, which meiosis would not do.