Phenotype or genotype evidence for four land snails
A student was given information about four species of land snail, W, X, Y and Z.
| Species | Shell colour | Number of whorls in the shell | Similarity of the base sequence of gene G to that of species W / % |
|---|---|---|---|
| W | brown | 5 | 100 |
| X | brown | 5 | 84 |
| Y | yellow-banded | 4 | 97 |
| Z | yellow-banded | 6 | 91 |
(a) Which statement explains why the data in the last column are genotypic evidence? (1)
A They compare observable characteristics of the snails.
B They compare the base sequences of the snails' DNA.
C They show which snails can interbreed.
D They are affected by the environment in which the snails live.
(b) Identify the species that is most closely related to species W. (1)
(c) Give a reason why classifying these snails by shell colour could suggest the wrong relationships. (1)
- 1
(a) The genotype is the genetic make-up of an organism, so comparing the order of bases in a gene compares genotypes. Answer: B (1)
- 2
(a) Why the others are wrong: A describes phenotypic evidence (such as shell colour and number of whorls). C describes the test in the species concept, not a comparison of DNA. D is wrong because the base sequence of a gene is inherited and is not changed by the environment; it is the phenotype that is affected by the environment.
- 3
(b) The species with the highest percentage similarity of base sequence to W has the most recent common ancestor with W: species Y (97%) (1)
- 4
(c) X has the same shell colour (and the same number of whorls) as W, yet it is the least similar in base sequence (84%). Shell colour can be affected by the environment, or can evolve to be similar in unrelated species living in similar habitats, so similar colour does not show a recent common ancestor (1). Also accept: it is a single feature, whereas a base sequence compares many bases.
Answer
(a) B (b) Species Y (97% similar). (c) Shell colour can be influenced by the environment / similar colours can evolve in unrelated species, so it need not show a recent common ancestor (X looks like W but is only 84% similar).
Examiner tip
In (b) name the species and, if asked, quote the value: Y at 97%. Do not choose X because it looks most like W; the question is about relationships, and the genotype data override a shared shell colour. In (c), stating that shell colour is a phenotype is not enough: say why a phenotype can mislead (environmental effect or similar features evolving in unrelated species).