Comparative advantage and gains from trade
Why trade pays.
Absolute advantage. Country can produce a good using FEWER inputs than another country.
Comparative advantage. Country has LOWER OPPORTUNITY COST in producing a good. This is the basis for mutually beneficial trade — even when one country is absolutely better at everything.
Worked example. Two countries, two goods:
| Cars (per worker) | Cloth (per worker) | |
|---|---|---|
| Country A | 10 | 50 |
| Country B | 4 | 30 |
Country A has absolute advantage in both. But:
- A's opportunity cost of 1 car = 5 cloth.
- B's opportunity cost of 1 car = 7.5 cloth.
A has lower opportunity cost in CARS; B has lower opportunity cost in CLOTH (1 cloth costs 0.2 cars in A vs 0.133 cars in B — so B is relatively better at cloth).
If A specialises in cars, B in cloth, and they trade, BOTH consume more than they could in autarky.
Benefits of trade:
- Lower prices for consumers (cheaper imports).
- More variety of goods.
- Larger markets allow scale economies.
- Competition from imports pressures domestic firms to improve efficiency.
- Faster growth — Korea, Singapore, China all grew rapidly via trade.
- Technology transfer — adopting better methods from abroad.
- Reduced inflation through cheap imports.
Costs of trade:
- Job displacement in sectors hit by imports (e.g. US manufacturing, "China shock" of 2000s).
- Wage stagnation for low-skill workers in advanced economies.
- Dependence on imports (food, energy security) — vulnerable to disruption.
- Loss of infant industries that could become globally competitive with protection.
- Environmental damage — production shifted to countries with weak regulation.
- Cultural homogenisation.
- Sovereignty concerns — trade rules limit national policy.
Distributional effects. Trade has winners (consumers, exporters, multinationals) and losers (import-competing workers). NET gains exist but compensation programmes are often inadequate.
Terms of trade. ToT = (index of export prices) ÷ (index of import prices) × 100.
Improvement (ToT rises) = each unit of exports buys MORE imports. Beneficial. Deterioration is harmful.
- Comparative advantage = lower opportunity cost.
- Both countries gain from specialisation + trade.
- Benefits: lower prices, variety, growth.
- Costs: displacement, dependence, environment.