Choosing the cation with the greatest polarising power
Which cation has the greatest polarising power?
A K⁺
B Ca²⁺
C Na⁺
D Mg²⁺
(1)
- 1
Polarising power increases with greater charge and smaller ionic radius (a higher charge density). Mg²⁺ carries a 2+ charge and has only two occupied shells, so it is the smallest of the four ions with the highest charge. D (1)
- 2
Distractors. A K⁺ has only a 1+ charge and is the largest ion here (three occupied shells), so it has the lowest polarising power. B Ca²⁺ has the same 2+ charge as Mg²⁺ but an extra occupied shell, so it is larger and less polarising. C Na⁺ is about the same size as Ca²⁺ but has only a 1+ charge, so it is less polarising than Mg²⁺.
Answer
D
Examiner tip
Both factors must be applied together: charge alone points to B or D, and size alone points to C or D. Only Mg²⁺ wins on both. Candidates who choose B have remembered 'charge' but not that Ca²⁺ has an extra shell of electrons.