Positive 2,4-DNPH but no change with Fehling's solution
Which compound gives an orange precipitate with 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine (2,4-DNPH) but no change when warmed with Fehling's solution?
A pentanal
B pentan-2-ol
C pentan-2-one
D pentanoic acid
(1)
- 1
2,4-DNPH gives an orange precipitate with any aldehyde or ketone (a C=O group in a carbonyl compound). Fehling's solution is reduced only by aldehydes. Pentan-2-one is a ketone, so it is positive with 2,4-DNPH and negative with Fehling's. C (1)
- 2
Distractors. A is wrong: pentanal is an aldehyde, so it also turns Fehling's solution from blue to a red precipitate. B is wrong: pentan-2-ol has no C=O group, so there is no precipitate with 2,4-DNPH. D is wrong: the C=O in a carboxylic acid does not react with 2,4-DNPH.
Answer
C
Examiner tip
Carboxylic acids contain C=O but are not carbonyl compounds for the purposes of the 2,4-DNPH test — a common trap. Learn each test as a pair: 2,4-DNPH detects aldehydes and ketones; Fehling's, Benedict's and Tollens' separate aldehydes from ketones.