Government support clearly matters. New businesses are refused credit precisely because they have no trading record, so a grant or a low-cost loan may be the only finance available at the point where it is needed most. Since running out of cash is the commonest reason start-ups close, help arriving at that moment can be decisive. Advice and training schemes also address inexperience, which is what causes many founders to mismanage costs or misjudge their market.
Other factors look more important, though. Whether there is real demand for the product matters more than anything: no amount of support will save a business selling something people do not want. The skill and determination of the entrepreneur shapes every decision the business makes, and support cannot substitute for judgement. The level of competition and the state of the economy also lie outside the founder's control and can sink a well-run business regardless of any assistance.
There is also a question about what support actually does. Government help is usually available at the start, whereas many businesses fail in their second or third year when the grants have ended. It may therefore delay failure rather than prevent it, and a business that depends on support to survive is arguably not viable.
On balance, government support is not the most important factor — demand for the product and the ability of the entrepreneur come first, because support without either is wasted. Its real value is different: it removes one specific obstacle, the shortage of start-up finance, for businesses that are otherwise sound. That makes it important for a particular kind of failure rather than the main determinant of survival.
This depends on the business and the economy. Where finance is very hard to obtain, or in a downturn when lending is restricted, support becomes far more significant — it may then be the only thing standing between a viable business and closure.