The business should allow home working for part of the week rather than permanently for everyone.
The case for permanent home working is substantial. The business would need far less office space, cutting rent, heating and lighting — usually one of its largest fixed costs. It could recruit from anywhere rather than only from commuting distance, widening the pool of applicants considerably, and it would keep employees who would otherwise resign when they moved or their circumstances changed. Many employees value the time and cost saved by not travelling, and some work more productively without the interruptions of an office.
There are serious objections. Supervision becomes harder, since managers cannot see what is happening and must learn to manage by measured output instead — a change many find difficult. The informal communication of an office disappears, and with it the quick questions and overheard conversations through which problems surface early and new employees learn. Training and induction are markedly harder at a distance, so new staff take longer to become effective. Not every employee has a suitable place to work at home, and some become isolated, which harms both wellbeing and commitment to the business.
The decisive point is that these arguments do not conflict — they apply to different things. The cost and recruitment benefits come from needing less office space, which a business achieves whether staff attend one day a week or none. The problems of supervision, communication and training come from staff never being together, which regular attendance solves. A hybrid arrangement captures most of the benefit while avoiding most of the cost.
I therefore reject permanent home working for all employees, not because the benefits are doubtful but because they can be obtained without accepting the drawbacks. The business should also treat new and experienced staff differently: a new employee needs the office far more than someone who has done the job for five years. This assumes the work is genuinely suited to remote working — where the job requires being physically present, the question does not arise.