A hierarchy that is too tall
Delta Logistics (DL)
Delta Logistics (DL) delivers parcels for online retailers. It employs 610 people across 14 depots and has seven levels in its hierarchy.
Each depot manager supervises only three supervisors, and each supervisor supervises five drivers. Managers describe their spans of control as narrow.
A depot manager who wants to buy a replacement van must get approval from three levels above. The last request took 19 days, during which a delivery round ran short of vehicles.
DL's largest customer has complained that DL is "slow to respond when something goes wrong".
The finance director notes that the four middle-management levels cost DL about $1.6 million a year in salaries.
Staff surveys show drivers feel they have little responsibility and are rarely asked for their views.
Explain two advantages and two disadvantages to DL of widening the spans of control of its depot managers.
- Advantage 1:
- Advantage 2:
- Disadvantage 1:
- Disadvantage 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of DL. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three ways DL could speed up its decision-making. Which should DL use? Justify your answer.
- •Delayering — remove two levels of middle management
- •Delegate spending authority to depot managers
- •Reorganise into regional divisions, each with its own management
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
Wider spans allow fewer levels in the hierarchy
DL has seven levels, which is why a van request needed approval three levels up
- Application:
Communication is faster with fewer levels to pass through
DL's largest customer has complained that it is slow to respond when something goes wrong
- Application:
Fewer managers reduces salary costs
DL's middle management costs about $1.6 million a year
- Application:
Managers may be overloaded with too many subordinates
a DL depot manager currently supervises three supervisors and would supervise many more
- Application:
Less close supervision of each subordinate
risky for DL where drivers operate alone away from the depot
- Application:
It requires more delegation, which needs trust and training
DL's drivers already report having little responsibility, so the change would be large
Full-mark answer
Advantage 1: Wider spans of control allow the hierarchy to have fewer levels (1). DL has seven levels, which is why a simple van purchase had to be approved three levels above the depot manager (1 app).
Advantage 2: Communication becomes faster because messages pass through fewer levels (1). This matters to DL because its largest customer has complained that it is slow to respond when something goes wrong (1 app).
Disadvantage 1: Managers can be overloaded when they supervise too many people (1). A DL depot manager currently oversees only three supervisors, so the increase would be a big change (1 app).
Disadvantage 2: There is less close supervision of each subordinate (1). That is a risk at DL, where drivers work alone away from the depot and cannot easily be monitored (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Delayering — remove two levels of middle management
For
Cuts a large part of the $1.6 million middle-management cost
Shortens the chain of command directly, so approvals stop taking 19 days
Improves the speed of response the largest customer is complaining about
Against
Redundancies damage morale and cost money in the short term
Remaining managers take on wider spans and may be overloaded
Experience and knowledge leave with the managers who go
Delegate spending authority to depot managers
For
A depot manager could replace a van immediately instead of waiting 19 days
Cheap and quick to introduce — it is a change of policy, not of structure
Increases responsibility for managers and, through them, for drivers who feel ignored
Keeps all 610 staff, avoiding redundancy costs and disruption
Against
Depot managers may make poor spending decisions without training
Does not reduce the $1.6 million management cost
Requires spending limits and monitoring to prevent overspending
The seven levels remain, so other decisions may still be slow
Reorganise into regional divisions, each with its own management
For
Decisions are made closer to the 14 depots and their customers
Regional managers can be held accountable for their own results
Suits a business spread across many locations
Against
Adds a management layer rather than removing one, raising costs above $1.6 million
Duplicates functions across regions
A large reorganisation is disruptive and slow to complete
Does not by itself shorten the approval chain that caused the 19-day delay
Model recommendation
DL should delegate spending authority to its depot managers.
This targets the actual failure described in the case. The problem is not that DL has managers, it is that a depot manager cannot authorise a replacement van without going three levels up, which cost 19 days and left a round short of vehicles. Delegating spending authority fixes that immediately, costs almost nothing, and gives drivers and managers the responsibility the staff survey says they lack.
I rejected delayering as the first step because it is drastic and irreversible. It would save part of the $1.6 million, but making managers redundant damages morale at a firm already struggling with responsiveness, and DL may find it has removed people it needs.
I rejected regional divisions because they add management rather than removing it. DL's costs would rise above $1.6 million, and the approval chain that caused the 19-day delay would still exist.
This depends on DL setting clear spending limits and training depot managers, otherwise fast decisions simply become expensive ones. If delegation works, delayering becomes a sensible second step once it is clear which levels add nothing.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to DL specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
610 employees across 14 depots with seven levels of hierarchy
- •
depot managers supervise only three supervisors; supervisors supervise five drivers
- •
a van purchase needed approval from three levels above and took 19 days
- •
a delivery round ran short of vehicles while waiting
- •
DL's largest customer says it is slow to respond when something goes wrong
- •
middle management costs about $1.6 million a year
- •
drivers report little responsibility and are rarely consulted
Examiner tip
Distinguish the terms precisely: span of control is how many people one manager supervises, chain of command is how many levels a message passes through, and delayering removes levels. They are related but not the same, and questions often reward the candidate who uses the right one. Here the 19-day delay is a chain-of-command problem, not a span problem.