Inspecting faults out, or building quality in
Pinnacle Motors (PM)
Pinnacle Motors (PM) assembles electric scooters. It produces 4 000 scooters a month on a flow production line and employs 130 people.
PM currently uses quality control: two inspectors check every scooter at the end of the line. Faulty scooters are stripped down and rebuilt.
Last month 240 scooters failed inspection. Reworking each one costs PM about $85.
A further 60 faulty scooters reached customers and were returned. PM estimates each return costs $310 once transport, replacement and lost goodwill are counted.
PM's production manager says: "By the time we find a fault, we have already paid to build it. We find faults; we do not prevent them."
Retraining all 130 staff in quality assurance would cost about $95 000 and take three months, during which output would fall by roughly 10%.
Explain two advantages and two disadvantages to PM of its current system of quality control by end-of-line inspection.
- Advantage 1:
- Advantage 2:
- Disadvantage 1:
- Disadvantage 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of PM. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three ways PM could reduce the cost of poor quality. Which should PM use? Justify your answer.
- •Add two more end-of-line inspectors
- •Retrain all 130 staff in quality assurance
- •Keep the current system but tighten supplier checks on parts
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
Inspection stops most faulty goods reaching customers
PM's inspectors caught 240 of the 300 faulty scooters last month
- Application:
Only a small number of staff need quality training
PM trains two inspectors rather than all 130 employees
- Application:
It is simple to operate on a flow production line
PM can check every scooter at one point at the end of the line
- Application:
Faults are found only after the money has been spent
PM pays about $85 to rework each of the 240 scooters it has already built
- Application:
Some faults still reach customers
60 faulty scooters got through last month, costing PM about $310 each
- Application:
Workers are not responsible for their own quality
PM's production manager says the system finds faults rather than preventing them
Full-mark answer
Advantage 1: Inspection prevents most faulty goods reaching customers (1). PM's two inspectors caught 240 of the 300 faulty scooters produced last month (1 app).
Advantage 2: Only a few staff need quality training (1). PM trains two inspectors rather than all 130 of its employees (1 app).
Disadvantage 1: Faults are only found after the money has been spent (1). PM pays about $85 to rework each of the 240 scooters it has already fully built (1 app).
Disadvantage 2: Some faults still reach customers (1). 60 faulty scooters got through last month, and PM estimates each return costs $310 (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Add two more end-of-line inspectors
For
Cheap and quick compared with retraining 130 staff
Would catch more of the 60 scooters currently reaching customers
No disruption to output
Against
Does nothing about the 240 scooters already being reworked at $85 each
Still finds faults rather than preventing them, exactly as the production manager says
Adds permanent salary cost for no reduction in faults produced
More inspection cannot catch every fault
Retrain all 130 staff in quality assurance
For
Attacks the cause: quality is built in rather than inspected afterwards
Would reduce both the $20 400 of rework and the $18 600 of returns
Gives workers responsibility, which can improve motivation
One-off cost of $95 000 against a recurring monthly loss
Against
$95 000 is a large sum to find up front
Output falls about 10% for three months during training
Benefits are not guaranteed and take time to appear
Some staff may resist taking on responsibility for quality
Keep the current system but tighten supplier checks on parts
For
Cheaper than retraining everyone
Faulty parts are a plausible cause of assembly faults
Little disruption to PM's own production
Against
The case does not say parts are the cause of the faults
May fix only a share of the problem
Suppliers may raise prices if checks are tightened
Leaves the inspect-at-the-end approach untouched
Model recommendation
PM should retrain all 130 staff in quality assurance.
Poor quality is costing PM about $39 000 a month — $20 400 reworking 240 scooters at $85 and $18 600 on 60 returns at $310. Against that, the $95 000 training cost pays for itself in about two and a half months if the problem is eliminated, or about five months if it is only halved. More importantly it changes the cause: as the production manager says, PM currently pays to build faults and then pays again to fix them.
I rejected adding inspectors because it treats the symptom. Two more people at the end of the line would catch a few more of the 60 that escape, but PM would still be building and reworking 240 faulty scooters a month at $85 each, and carrying more salary cost for it.
I rejected tightening supplier checks because nothing in the case identifies parts as the cause. Spending money on a guess, while leaving the inspect-at-the-end system in place, risks fixing nothing.
This depends on PM coping with roughly 10% lower output for three months. Given it produces 4 000 scooters a month, that is about 400 fewer per month — PM should check it can meet orders during the changeover, perhaps by building stock first.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to PM specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
4 000 scooters a month on a flow production line, 130 employees
- •
quality control relies on two inspectors at the end of the line
- •
240 scooters failed inspection last month at about $85 each to rework
- •
60 faulty scooters reached customers, costing about $310 each
- •
the production manager says faults are found, not prevented
- •
retraining all 130 staff would cost about $95 000 over three months
- •
output would fall about 10% during retraining
Examiner tip
The cost of poor quality is calculable here: 240 × $85 = $20 400 and 60 × $310 = $18 600, about $39 000 a month. Setting that against a one-off $95 000 turns a vague "quality assurance is better" answer into a justified recommendation. Keep the terms straight: quality control inspects output, quality assurance builds quality in at every stage.