A stronger currency cuts both ways
Siena Ceramics (SC)
Siena Ceramics (SC) makes decorative tiles. It employs 190 people and had revenue of $7.4 million last year.
62% of SC's revenue comes from exports, mainly to two neighbouring countries.
SC's home currency has risen about 12% against those countries' currencies over six months.
A tile that SC sells for 40 units of its home currency now costs a foreign buyer about 44.80 of their own — about 12% more.
About 30% of SC's production costs are imported clay and glazes, which have become roughly 12% cheaper.
SC's export orders have fallen 18% since the currency began to rise. Home-market orders are unchanged.
A competitor in one export market has kept its prices flat and is winning SC's customers.
Explain two ways the stronger currency harms SC and two ways it benefits SC.
- Harm 1:
- Harm 2:
- Benefit 1:
- Benefit 2:
4 marks for the points themselves, 4 marks for explaining each one in the context of SC. Half the marks are application.
Consider the advantages and disadvantages of the following three responses SC could make. Which should SC choose? Justify your answer.
- •Cut export prices to restore the old foreign price
- •Hold prices and focus on the home market
- •Cut export prices partially, funded by the cheaper imports
Mark scheme and model answers
Part (a) — 8 marks
Acceptable points — you need 4
- Application:
Exports become more expensive for foreign buyers, so demand falls
SC's 40-unit tile now costs a foreign buyer about 44.80, and export orders have fallen 18%
- Application:
The firm loses competitiveness against foreign rivals
a competitor has kept prices flat and is winning SC's customers
- Application:
A large share of revenue is exposed
62% of SC's $7.4 million revenue comes from exports
- Application:
Imported raw materials become cheaper
30% of SC's production costs are imported clay and glazes, now about 12% cheaper
- Application:
Lower input costs allow a price cut without losing all the margin
SC could use its cheaper imports to fund a reduction in its export price
- Application:
Imported equipment becomes cheaper to buy
SC could re-equip its factory more cheaply than before
Full-mark answer
Harm 1: Exports become dearer for foreign buyers, so demand falls (1). SC's 40-unit tile now costs a foreign buyer about 44.80, and its export orders have fallen 18% (1 app).
Harm 2: SC loses competitiveness against foreign rivals (1). A competitor has kept its prices flat and is taking SC's customers in one export market (1 app).
Benefit 1: Imported raw materials become cheaper (1). About 30% of SC's production costs are imported clay and glazes, now roughly 12% cheaper (1 app).
Benefit 2: Cheaper inputs can fund a price cut (1). SC could pass some of that saving on to foreign buyers to defend the 62% of revenue that comes from exports (1 app).
Part (b) — 12 marks
| Level | Marks | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | 9-12 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of two or more options. Well-justified recommendation. Candidates discussing all three options, in context, with a well-justified recommendation that includes why the alternatives were rejected, should be rewarded with the top marks in the band. |
| 2 | 5-8 | Sound application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts using appropriate terminology. Detailed discussion of at least one option. Judgement with some justification / some evaluation of the choice made. |
| 1 | 1-4 | Limited application of knowledge and understanding of relevant business concepts. Limited ability to discuss the options, with little or no explanation. Simple judgement with limited justification. |
Cut export prices to restore the old foreign price
For
Directly answers the 18% fall in export orders
Cheaper imported materials — 30% of costs, 12% cheaper — help fund the cut
Defends $4.588 million of export revenue and the competitor's gains
Against
Restoring the old foreign price needs a cut of about 10.7%, more than the input saving covers
Margin falls on every export sale
Prices are hard to raise again if the currency falls back
Hold prices and focus on the home market
For
Home orders are unchanged, so the market is stable
Protects the margin on every sale
No risk of a price war with the competitor
Against
The home market cannot absorb 62% of revenue moving to it
SC would be abandoning customers the competitor is already taking
Export market share, once lost, is expensive to regain
190 jobs depend on total output, not just home sales
Cut export prices partially, funded by the cheaper imports
For
Uses the windfall on 30% of costs rather than cutting into margin
Narrows the gap the competitor is exploiting without matching it fully
Keeps some price rise, so margin is partly protected
Reversible if the currency falls back
Against
A partial cut may not be enough to win back all of the 18%
The competitor may cut further in response
Adds complexity to pricing across two export markets
Model recommendation
SC should cut export prices partially, funded by the saving on imported materials.
This uses the one benefit the currency move has handed SC. Imported clay and glazes are 30% of production costs and about 12% cheaper, and passing that saving through narrows the price gap without cutting into margin.
A full cut is the wrong size. Restoring the original foreign price needs a reduction of about 10.7%, and the input saving covers only part of that, so SC would be funding the rest from profit on 62% of its revenue.
I rejected retreating to the home market. Home orders are stable but the home market cannot absorb the $4.588 million that exports currently earn, and SC would be conceding customers to a competitor who is already taking them — share that is expensive to win back.
I rejected doing nothing on price because the 18% fall is continuing while a rival holds its prices flat.
This depends on how long the currency stays strong. A partial cut is the right response to a move that may reverse; if the rise proves permanent, SC will need a more fundamental answer, such as sourcing more materials abroad or producing in an export market.
Did you use the case?
Application marks are given for referring to SC specifically. Check your answer against the details you could have quoted.
- •
revenue $7.4 million with 62% from exports — about $4.588 million
- •
the home currency has risen about 12%
- •
a tile priced at 40 units now costs a foreign buyer about 44.80
- •
30% of production costs are imported and are now about 12% cheaper
- •
export orders have fallen 18%
- •
home-market orders are unchanged
- •
a competitor has kept prices flat and is taking SC's customers
- •
190 employees
Examiner tip
Exchange rate questions almost always cut both ways for an exporter that also imports — work out both sides before concluding. A useful memory aid is SPICED: Strong Pound, Imports Cheaper, Exports Dearer. Note the arithmetic asymmetry: a 12% rise in the currency needs about a 10.7% price cut to offset, because 40 ÷ 1.12 = 35.71, not 40 × 0.88.