A counter-example to a false identity
Dev says that for all values of and .
Give an example to show that Dev is wrong. [1]
Model answer
Take and .
, so Dev is wrong.
Where the marks are
- 1
B1 for any pair of non-zero values with both sides evaluated correctly and shown to be different
Why this scores
Evaluates both sides. The script works out and separately and shows they differ. Just writing ", " does not show anything.
Avoids zero. If either or is the two sides are equal, so a counter-example with a zero fails.