Which change does not speed up zinc and acid? (Paper 1)
A student reacts 2.0 g of zinc granules with 50 cm³ of dilute sulfuric acid at 20 °C.
Which change would not increase the rate of the reaction?
- A using 2.0 g of zinc powder instead of zinc granules
- B warming the acid to 40 °C
- C using 100 cm³ of the same dilute sulfuric acid
- D using sulfuric acid of a higher concentration
- 1
Powder has a larger surface area (A), a higher temperature gives more frequent and more energetic collisions (B), and a higher concentration puts more particles in the same volume (D) — all three increase the rate. A larger volume of the same acid has the same concentration: the number of acid particles in each cm³ does not change, so the collision frequency at the zinc surface does not change: C. (1)
Answer
C — using 100 cm³ of the same dilute sulfuric acid.
Examiner tip
Rate depends on concentration, not on the total volume of solution. Doubling the volume of the same acid doubles the number of acid particles, but it also doubles the space they are in, so the number in the same volume — and the frequency of collisions — is unchanged.
Most common mistake: choosing C because "more acid means more particles, so more collisions". More acid can mean more product if the acid is the limiting reactant, but it does not make the reaction faster.