Which describes the water movement in a potato cylinder? (Paper 1)
A cylinder of potato is placed in a concentrated sucrose solution for one hour.
Which describes the main movement of water?
- A into the potato cells by osmosis
- B out of the potato cells by osmosis
- C out of the potato cells by active transport
- D into the potato cells by active transport
- 1
Water moves by osmosis, which is passive — so C and D, which need energy from respiration, are wrong. In osmosis water moves from a dilute solution to a more concentrated solution. The sucrose solution outside is more concentrated than the cell contents, so water moves out of the cells: B. (1)
Answer
B — out of the potato cells by osmosis.
Examiner tip
Decide two things separately: which process (water always moves by osmosis), then which direction (towards the more concentrated solution). Only one option gets both right.
Most common mistake: choosing A by thinking of water moving "from high to low" without saying high or low what. Anchor the direction to the solutions: water moves from the dilute solution to the concentrated one.