The syllabus (LO 2.1.7) draws an explicit distinction between a shift of a curve (triggered by a non-price determinant) and a movement along a curve (triggered by a change in the good's own price). The question asks whether real-world observed price changes mostly reflect shifts rather than movements — an evaluative claim that requires both diagnostic and empirical reasoning.
Case supporting the view. A movement along a curve is, strictly speaking, triggered by a change in the good's OWN price with no change in demand or supply conditions. But in a dynamic economy, demand and supply conditions are rarely stable: incomes, tastes, costs, technology, policies and expectations change continuously. Nearly every observed price change in a market can be traced to a change in one or more of these non-price determinants — i.e. to a shift of demand or supply, or both. For example, the sharp rise in the price of petrol in 2022 reflected supply-side shocks (Russian export sanctions, reduced OPEC output) — a leftward shift of supply, not a movement along a stable curve. Similarly, the collapse in the price of consumer electronics over two decades reflects rightward shifts of supply driven by technology improvements, not downward movements along a stable curve. The underlying economic reality is that curves move all the time, so most observed changes in price are shift-driven.
Case against the view / qualifications. The claim overstates the case in two ways. First, in markets where supply or demand IS temporarily stable, price changes DO reflect movements along one curve driven by a shift of the OTHER. For example, if supply is unchanged and demand shifts rightward, the OBSERVED price rise and quantity rise reflect BOTH a shift of demand AND a movement UP along supply. In this case, the movement along supply is a real, meaningful part of the explanation, and ignoring it mis-represents the mechanism. Second, in markets with sticky prices or administered pricing (regulated utilities, long-term contracts), observed prices may be slow to reflect either shifts or movements, so neither framework alone explains the pattern well. Third, in short-run markets with highly inelastic supply (e.g. housing in the next week, a specific antique), a demand shift leads almost entirely to a movement up a nearly-vertical supply curve — the price change comes mostly through the movement, with the shift translating almost one-for-one into a higher equilibrium price along a near-fixed supply.
Balancing the two. The two framings are not alternatives but complements. In any given price change there is usually a SHIFT (change in a non-price determinant that causes a curve to move) AND a MOVEMENT (a change in the own-price that re-locates the market along the other curve). The question is which does more of the explanatory work. For most observed price changes in real markets, the shift is the ultimate cause (what changed) and the movement is the mechanical response along the other curve (how the market cleared at the new price). The claim 'most price changes reflect shifts' is therefore correct about the CAUSE of change but incomplete as a description of the MECHANISM by which the market reaches the new price.
Reasoned judgement. The view is correct as a statement about causation: in most real markets, the ultimate trigger of a price change is a change in a non-price determinant — a shift of one or both curves. The view is incomplete as a description of mechanism: the shift translates into an observed price change via a movement along the other curve, and that movement is a real and necessary part of the story. The strongest formulation is therefore: most observed price changes are caused by shifts of the demand or supply curve, but the market clears at the new price through a corresponding movement along the other curve. For practical analysis — diagnosing why a price changed, forecasting whether it will persist, designing a policy response — the shift is the actionable concept and the movement is the resulting adjustment. On this reading the view is correct, with a technical qualification that the mechanism itself contains both elements.