Case supporting the view. NNI differs from GDP in two conceptually important ways. First, it adds net income from abroad (converting GDP into GNI), so it measures income accruing to residents rather than output produced within the borders. Second, it subtracts depreciation (converting GNI into NNI), so it measures income net of the capital stock worn out during production. On the first adjustment, NNI gives a more accurate reading of what citizens actually earn — important in labour-exporting economies (large positive net income from abroad) or in countries with heavy foreign ownership of domestic capital (large negative net income from abroad). On the second adjustment, NNI reveals whether current income is being generated by running down the capital base: a country whose GDP is rising by 3% a year while its capital stock depreciates by 4% a year is actually becoming poorer in productive-capacity terms, and GDP alone hides this. In both respects, NNI corresponds more closely to what 'economic performance' means in a welfare-relevant sense.
Case against the view. The adjustments are not without cost. First, depreciation is an estimate, not a directly observed quantity: statistical agencies impute it from assumptions about capital lifetimes that differ across countries and over time. This introduces measurement noise into NNI that GDP avoids, which is why most countries report GDP as their headline figure despite NNI's conceptual superiority. Second, GDP is more timely: NNI depends on both net-income-from-abroad data (which lags) and depreciation estimates (which arrive later still), so it is less useful for short-term macroeconomic management. Third, for several specific purposes GDP remains the better measure: tracking domestic employment and output (jobs and factories produce GDP, not NNI), measuring tax base (consumption and production taxes are levied on domestic activity, not residents' net income), and comparing across countries where net income from abroad is small (for large closed economies the GDP → NNI gap is a few per cent and the two measures move together). Fourth, NNI shares many of GDP's broader limitations as a welfare measure — neither captures distribution, informal activity, environmental damage or non-market production — so the gain from switching is more modest than the formula suggests.
Reasoned judgement. The claim that NNI is 'a better measure of economic performance' is partly right but overstated. On the specific dimensions NNI corrects for — residents' income rather than domestic output, income net of capital consumption — it is unambiguously the more welfare-relevant figure, so for cross-country living-standards comparison, long-run sustainability analysis, and small-open-economy welfare assessment, NNI is the better measure. But GDP remains the correct measure for domestic activity, employment, tax-base analysis and short-term macro management, and NNI is noisier because depreciation is estimated. The strongest formulation is therefore conditional: NNI is a better welfare-and-sustainability measure, GDP a better domestic-activity-and-tax-base measure, and the gap between them matters most in small open economies with large cross-border income flows or heavy capital intensity. 'Better' depends on the question being asked, and the honest answer is to report both.