The claim is that an AD-rightward shift always raises real output. The AD/AS model shows this is correct in some circumstances and false in others; a reasoned evaluation depends on the slope of SRAS, the position of the economy on LRAS, and the degree of nominal rigidity.
Case supporting the view. On an upward-sloping SRAS curve, a rightward shift of AD from AD₁ to AD₂ moves the macroeconomic equilibrium up and to the right. Real output rises from Y₁ to Y₂ because higher planned expenditure induces firms to raise production; nominal wages are sticky in the short run, so profit margins widen as the price level rises, and firms respond by hiring more labour and running more shifts. Employment rises alongside output through the derived-demand mechanism. On this baseline, the claim is correct.
Case against the view / qualifications. The 'always' in the claim is too strong, for three distinct reasons.
First, if the economy is on the vertical section of a three-section LRAS, or on a classical vertical LRAS at Yf, an increase in AD cannot raise real output at all. With every factor of production fully employed, extra planned expenditure cannot call forth extra output; the whole of the AD rise feeds into the price level and real output stays at Yf. This is the standard 'overheating' outcome. Employment likewise cannot rise beyond the full-employment level, though frictional and structural unemployment remain.
Second, in the long run on a classical vertical LRAS, even an AD rise that initially raises real output is a short-run phenomenon only. The initial rise in the price level eventually feeds through to higher nominal wages and other input costs; SRAS shifts to the left; the economy returns to Yf at a permanently higher price level. In the long run, the AD-rightward shift leaves real output unchanged — only the price level is permanently higher. This is the 'money is neutral in the long run' result.
Third, if SRAS simultaneously shifts leftward (through a cost shock), the net effect on real output can be zero or even negative despite the AD rise. The combined effect depends on relative magnitudes: if the cost shock dominates, real output falls even as AD rises. This is a realistic scenario — Country X in the data-response example above combines a stimulus with an oil shock, and the real-output outcome depends on which effect wins.
Evaluation of the three cases. The baseline AD-rightward-raises-output result is strongest when (i) the economy has substantial spare capacity (horizontal or middle section of a three-section LRAS), (ii) SRAS is not shifting adversely at the same time, (iii) the time horizon is short (so the self-correction of a vertical LRAS has not yet operated), and (iv) nominal wages are sticky (so the SRAS leftward adjustment is slow). When all four conditions hold, an AD rise raises real output and employment with little price-level cost. When any one of them fails — full employment, simultaneous cost shock, long time horizon, flexible wages — the output response is partial, zero or negative.
Reasoned judgement. The view 'AD rise always raises real output' is correct in the short run with spare capacity and no competing shock, and false under at least three well-defined circumstances: full employment, long-run adjustment on a vertical LRAS, and simultaneous adverse supply shocks. The useful formulation is: an AD rise raises real output when (and only when) the economy has unused capacity and no offsetting supply-side force. Policy-makers who assume the baseline relationship always holds — using fiscal stimulus near full capacity, for example — can produce higher prices without raising real output. The strongest statement is therefore that an AD rise is a necessary but not sufficient condition for a rise in real output; the sufficient condition is an AD rise combined with available productive capacity.