A depreciation of a floating exchange rate makes one unit of the domestic currency buy LESS foreign currency, which simultaneously makes exports cheaper abroad and imports more expensive at home. Whether this is a NET benefit for the domestic economy depends on which channel dominates and on the state of the economy at the time.
Case for the claim — depreciation benefits the economy. Cheaper exports in foreign currency raise foreign demand for the country's goods and services, lifting export volumes. More expensive imports in domestic currency encourage domestic buyers to switch from imports to domestically produced substitutes. Net exports (X−M) therefore rise, and aggregate demand AD=C+I+G+(X−M) shifts RIGHTWARD from AD1 to AD2. Along upward-sloping SRAS, equilibrium national income rises from (P1,Y1) to (P2,Y2): real output rises, firms facing stronger demand hire more workers, and cyclical unemployment falls. For an economy running BELOW full capacity — with a sizeable output gap and high unemployment — this is a clean growth-and-jobs boost: most of the AD rise feeds into real output rather than prices because SRAS is relatively flat in the slack-capacity region.
Case against — depreciation can harm the economy. The same depreciation raises the domestic-currency price of every imported good. Finished imported consumer goods become more expensive on the shelf; imported raw materials, energy and capital goods raise firms' unit costs. The DIRECT effect is a rise in the general price level — imported inflation. For a HIGHLY IMPORT-DEPENDENT economy (one that imports food, energy or key capital goods), this effect is large: real household disposable incomes fall, firms absorbing the cost shock may cut hiring, and the real cost of living rises. If the economy is at or near full capacity, the AD rise cannot be matched with more real output; SRAS is steep so the depreciation feeds mostly into higher prices rather than higher real GDP — the economy ends up with inflation and only a small output gain. Depreciation can also signal weakness to markets, triggering further capital outflow and additional unwanted depreciation, and if workers demand higher nominal wages to protect real pay, a wage-price spiral can push SRAS leftward and compound the inflation problem.
Reasoned judgement. A depreciation is MORE LIKELY to benefit the economy when (i) there is spare capacity so the AD rise translates mostly into real output rather than prices; (ii) the economy is not heavily import-dependent so the imported-inflation shock is small; (iii) foreign demand for exports is responsive to the lower foreign-currency price so the (X−M) rise is sizeable; and (iv) inflation expectations are well-anchored so the price-level rise does not spiral into a wage-price loop. It is LESS LIKELY to benefit when any of these conditions fails — in particular when the economy is at full capacity, is highly import-dependent, or has weak policy credibility. The claim 'depreciation ALWAYS benefits a domestic economy' is therefore too strong. The strongest formulation is: in the standard case of a floating-rate economy with spare capacity, moderate import dependence and anchored expectations, a modest depreciation is net beneficial; in the opposite case — a highly import-dependent economy at full capacity with unanchored expectations — a large depreciation can be net harmful.