Economic growth is a sustained rise in real GDP; economic development is a multi-dimensional rise in wellbeing covering health, education, equity and the environment. The question is whether the second is possible without the first. The evidence suggests it is possible under specific conditions but not in general.
Case that development is possible without substantial growth. Three mechanisms point this way. First, redistribution with existing output. A country that is already producing a given real GDP can raise HDI and lower MPI by redistributing more of that output through progressive taxation, transfer payments and state provision of health and education — without raising the aggregate. The Lorenz curve for disposable income shifts closer to the 45° line, and the resources freed for public services raise the health and education indices of the lower end of the distribution. Second, composition change towards public services. A country can hold real GDP constant while shifting its composition towards health, education and clean-water infrastructure — the components that drive HDI and MPI. The same GDP produces a higher HDI if more of it is spent on development outcomes rather than on luxury consumption. Third, historical cases. Cuba, Sri Lanka, Kerala (as a sub-national example) and Costa Rica have historically achieved HDI scores well above what their GNI per capita would predict, through sustained public investment in health and education at relatively low income. These cases establish that development without large growth is empirically possible.
Case that development without growth is largely impossible. Three mechanisms work against the view. First, public services are fiscally expensive. Universal health care, free schooling, clean-water infrastructure and poverty-reducing transfers require tax revenue, and tax revenue scales with real GDP. A low-income country trying to fund development without growth faces a tight fiscal constraint that limits what redistribution and public spending can achieve. Second, development has an income component. HDI, MPI and basic consumption all depend partly on real household income — nutrition, housing, energy, consumer durables — which cannot rise sustainably without a growing output base. A country that holds real GDP constant cannot raise material living standards for everyone; it can only redistribute them. Third, the successful major developers used growth. Korea, Taiwan, Singapore, Malaysia, China and Vietnam each used sustained real-GDP growth as the engine of development: HDI rose, life expectancy rose, mean schooling rose, poverty rates fell. For the countries that have moved the largest numbers of people out of poverty in modern history, growth was indispensable.
Qualifying mechanisms. Four conditions determine whether development without growth is viable. (i) The baseline income level. For a middle-income economy with existing fiscal capacity, redistribution and composition change can deliver substantial development improvements. For a low-income economy with narrow fiscal capacity, growth is essentially required. (ii) Public policy and administrative capacity. Development without growth requires a government capable of channelling existing output effectively into health, education and transfers; weak administration cannot deliver this. (iii) The dimension being targeted. For non-material dimensions (education, health, political freedom), redistribution and public spending can deliver gains at relatively low income. For material consumption dimensions (housing, nutrition at mass scale), real-income rises are essentially needed. (iv) The time horizon. Short-run development gains from redistribution can be substantial; long-run development gains at the scale China and Korea achieved require sustained growth.
Reasoned judgement. Development without substantial growth is possible in specific cases — middle-income economies with existing fiscal capacity and strong public administration can raise HDI and lower MPI through redistribution and composition change. Cuba, Sri Lanka, Kerala and Costa Rica are the empirical demonstrations. But it is not possible as a general strategy — the countries that have achieved the largest absolute reductions in poverty and the largest rises in HDI did so through sustained growth. The sharpest formulation is that growth is a necessary condition for mass development at low baselines and a sufficient condition for development only when combined with inclusive, sustainable and publicly-channelled policy. Development without growth is possible for specific countries pursuing specific dimensions of wellbeing from a specific starting point; it is not a general-purpose substitute for growth-led development.
The strongest reading of the question is therefore not 'yes' or 'no' but 'yes under conditions of middle-income starting point, strong administrative capacity and non-material development targets; no under conditions of low-income starting point, weak capacity and material-consumption targets'. The right policy framework in low- and middle-income economies combines sustained real-GDP growth with inclusive distribution and strong public services — the recipe that the successful East Asian developers used, and that the Kuznets curve downswing describes.