The claim mirrors the mainstream institutional arrangement in advanced economies: most central banks are given price stability as their primary (sometimes sole) legal mandate, with growth and employment pursued by fiscal and supply-side policy. The question is whether this institutional choice reflects a genuine ranking of importance or a narrower pragmatic judgement.
Case supporting the view. Three strands reinforce the primacy of price stability. First, it is a pre-condition for the other objectives: without stable prices, long-term planning collapses, savings are eroded, competitiveness is lost and the real return on investment becomes unpredictable. High inflation damages growth by discouraging investment and eroding real incomes; deflation damages employment through deferred spending and debt deflation. So price stability is not just one objective among three — it is the foundation on which the other two depend. Second, the institutional architecture of modern monetary policy — operationally independent central banks with inflation-targeting mandates (typically around 2%) — reflects a global consensus that reached by the 1990s: Volcker's disinflation (US, 1979-82) and the Bundesbank's record showed that a credible anti-inflation commitment delivers better long-run outcomes for growth AND employment than attempts to prioritise them directly. Third, inflation imposes CONCENTRATED costs on specific groups (unindexed savers, pensioners, fixed-income earners) that are difficult to address through other channels — price stability protects them automatically.
Case against the view. Three objections push back. First, the costs of modest inflation are MODEST — menu costs, shoe-leather costs, small redistributional effects, perhaps 1-1.5 percentage points of CPI mismeasurement bias — whereas the costs of unemployment are CONCENTRATED AND SEVERE (lost income, hysteresis, mental and physical health, family breakdown, higher crime rates). On a straight welfare comparison, high unemployment is more costly per unit than high inflation; the case for making price stability PRIMARY over low unemployment is therefore not watertight. Second, in a DEVELOPING economy with low real incomes and widespread poverty, growth is the mechanism that lifts living standards durably; a central-bank mandate focused solely on inflation would miss what matters most. Third, in a crisis — the global financial crisis, the Covid shock, a severe recession — the right primary objective is clearly to support employment and output, with inflation targeting temporarily relaxed; the view that price stability is ALWAYS the single most important objective fails this test.
Qualifications. The view also presumes that price stability is INSTRUMENTALLY compatible with the other objectives — that pursuing stable prices does not harm growth and employment. In the long run this is largely true (sustained high inflation damages both); in the short run it is less clearly true (a contractionary response to a cost-push shock deepens the output loss). The claim therefore holds more clearly over medium-to-long horizons than over the business cycle.
Reasoned judgement. For a stable, developed economy in normal times, the view is well-supported: price stability is the pre-condition for the other objectives, the institutional consensus reflects this, and modest inflation costs are easier to tolerate than the costs of inflation escalating or deflating. For a developing economy or an economy in crisis, however, the view is too strong — growth or employment may legitimately be the primary objective. The strongest formulation is therefore conditional: price stability is correctly the primary monetary objective in normal times for a developed economy with a credible central bank, but it is NOT the single most important objective in all contexts. The right institutional reading is that price stability is the primary MONETARY objective (hence the central bank's mandate), while growth and employment remain legitimate objectives of fiscal and supply-side policy — not that price stability dominates the other two in some absolute sense.