A high national debt is widely treated as a sign of fiscal weakness, but 'always damaging' is too strong a claim. Whether a high debt is damaging depends on why the debt was accumulated, what it financed, who the government owes, and what the alternative was.
Case that a high national debt IS damaging. The debt is a stock of past borrowing, and borrowing has to be serviced. Interest payments on the debt are a form of current spending that crowds out other spending priorities (schools, hospitals) or forces the government to raise taxes. If the debt is high relative to GDP, markets may demand a higher interest rate to lend further, raising the government's future borrowing cost and squeezing the budget further. A high debt also narrows the government's fiscal space in a future recession: a country already borrowing heavily may be unable to run large counter-cyclical deficits when they are most needed. In extreme cases, markets lose confidence that the debt will be serviced and the country faces a sovereign debt crisis.
Case that a high national debt is NOT always damaging. The purpose for which the debt was issued matters enormously. If the government borrowed to finance capital spending on productive infrastructure — railways, electrification, broadband, schools — then the resulting assets raise long-run productive capacity, so the economy's GDP (and future tax base) grows alongside the debt. In this case the debt is an investment, not a liability without return. Second, if the debt is largely owed domestically (held by the country's own citizens, pension funds and banks), interest payments stay within the country rather than flowing abroad — the debt is a redistribution of income, not a drain. Third, if the government borrows during a recession to raise AD (LO 5.2.7), the resulting output gain may be large enough that the debt-to-GDP ratio actually falls as GDP recovers, so the stock measure overstates the burden. Fourth, if the interest rate on the debt is below the economy's long-run growth rate, the debt is sustainable even without ever repaying the principal — new borrowing can roll the stock forward while the economy grows underneath it.
Factors on which the judgement turns. Four conditions determine whether a high debt is damaging. (i) Composition of the spending it financed — capital spending is less damaging than permanent current spending. (ii) Debt holders — domestic debt is less damaging than foreign-currency foreign debt. (iii) Growth of the economy — if g > r (growth rate above interest rate), the debt-to-GDP ratio falls over time without repayments; if r > g, it rises. (iv) Counterfactual — the right test is not whether a given level of debt is damaging in isolation but whether it is damaging compared with the alternative (higher taxes, lower spending or forgoing the counter-cyclical response).
Reasoned judgement. A high national debt is damaging when (i) it was accumulated to pay for routine current spending with no return, (ii) it is owed abroad in foreign currency, (iii) the growth rate is below the interest rate so the ratio rises mechanically, and (iv) interest payments crowd out high-return public investment. It is not necessarily damaging — and may be beneficial — when (i) the debt financed productive capital spending, (ii) it is held domestically, (iii) growth exceeds the interest rate, and (iv) the counterfactual (no borrowing) would have required a damaging cut in essential spending or produced a deeper recession. The sharper formulation is that the national debt is a stock whose economic significance depends on the flow that services it and on the assets and output behind it. The question is less 'is the debt high?' and more 'is it well-used, well-structured and sustainable?'. On balance, 'always damaging' is wrong; 'damaging under identifiable conditions' is correct.