The question tests whether capacity-expanding (supply-side, PPC-shifting) policies are always to be preferred over efficiency-improving (reallocation and utilisation) policies within the existing PPC.
Case supporting the view. An outward shift of the PPC raises the economy's maximum attainable output — it is the formal representation of economic growth, which is the long-run source of improvements in living standards. Policies that drive outward shifts — investment in education, infrastructure, research and development, and incentives for capital accumulation — have cumulative effects: each unit of extra capacity today enlarges the base from which further growth can be built tomorrow. Over long horizons, the compounding effect of outward shifts dominates any one-off efficiency gain within the current PPC. Historical evidence supports this: countries that have sustained outward PPC shifts over decades (through investment, education, and technology) have delivered dramatic improvements in average incomes, whereas countries that have focused only on redistributing existing output within the current frontier have seen stagnant long-run living standards.
Case against the view — qualifications. The claim 'always prioritise' is, however, too strong. Several qualifications apply.
First, efficiency gains can be large and immediate. If the economy is operating inside its PPC — because of unemployed labour, under-used capital or allocative inefficiency — moving to the frontier delivers a one-off output gain at zero opportunity cost. Where unemployment is high (a severe output gap), the welfare gain from this one-off move can exceed the short-run gain from any plausible outward shift. In a deep recession, prioritising capacity expansion over demand recovery would leave the extra capacity unused and could even damage the existing frontier through hysteresis.
Second, the two policy types are often complementary, not substitutes. Supply-side investment that shifts the PPC outward relies on an economy with resources available to invest — in a recession, investment itself depends on recovering activity, so efficiency-restoring (demand-side) policy must sometimes come first.
Third, outward-shifting policies carry opportunity costs of their own. Investment in education, R&D and infrastructure requires foregoing current consumption. If current citizens' living standards are already low (as in a developing economy), the trade-off between consumption today and growth tomorrow is not automatically resolved in favour of growth. The ethical weight placed on current vs future generations shapes the answer.
Fourth, not all shift-generating policies are equally effective. A badly-designed infrastructure programme or a politically-captured education reform can waste resources and deliver little outward shift, while a well-designed efficiency improvement (removing a trade restriction, reforming a factor market) can deliver immediate real gains. Policy effectiveness, not policy type, is what matters.
Fifth, distribution matters. An outward shift that benefits a narrow elite may deliver less welfare improvement than an efficiency gain that broadens access to existing output (e.g. redistribution to reduce absolute poverty). The PPC captures aggregate output, not its distribution.
Balancing the two. Outward-shift policies are the long-run source of growth and should be central to any sustainable development strategy. But 'always prioritise' goes further than the evidence supports. In the short run, where output gaps exist and resources are under-used, efficiency-restoring policies deliver quicker, larger welfare gains. The two policy types tend to be complementary: a country that shifts its PPC outward but then fails to use the capacity (through chronic unemployment or allocative distortion) achieves less than one that both expands and uses its frontier.
Reasoned judgement. The view holds in the long run and under full employment: once the economy is already on its frontier, further gains require shifting the frontier outward, and supply-side policy is the only lever. The view is overstated in the short run and under under-utilisation: when the economy is inside the PPC, moving to the frontier is cheaper and faster than shifting the frontier itself. The strongest formulation is: outward-shift policies are a long-run necessity but not a short-run universal priority — a rational policy-maker uses both types, with the balance between them depending on current utilisation, time horizon and distributional stakes. On that qualified reading the view is partly correct — it names the right long-run priority but mis-states its universality.