Cambridge International AS & A Level 9701 Chemistry · Syllabus 2025-2027
Stability constants, Kstab: Model Answers
Ten full-mark answers on Paper 4 / Paper 5 style questions about $K_{stab}$: defining and writing expressions, deducing units, comparing complexes to predict ligand exchange, calculating free-metal-ion concentrations, and explaining the entropy origin of the chelate effect. The final answers walk through a Paper 5 plan to determine $K_{stab}$ spectrophotometrically and a synoptic Paper 4 problem on the weak thiocyanato complex of iron(III).
Question 1Core[1 mark]
Q (1 mark). State what is meant by the stability constant, Kstab, of a complex ion.
Model answer
Kstab is the equilibrium constant for the formation of a complex ion from its constituent metal ion and ligands in a stated solvent (with [H2O] omitted when the solvent is water).
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (1 mark):
'Equilibrium constant for the formation of the complex from its constituent ions/molecules in a solvent' ✓
Examiner commentary: AO1. A one-mark definition is scored by wording. 'Formation of the complex' is essential — writing 'a measure of stability' loses the mark.
Question 2Core[2 marks]
Q (2 marks). Cobalt(II) reacts with concentrated aqueous ammonia to form a yellow-brown complex:
Write the Kstab expression for this reaction and state its units.
Model answer
Kstab=[[Co(H2O)6]2+][NH3]6[[Co(NH3)6]2+]; units mol⁻⁶ dm¹⁸.
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (2 marks):
Correct expression with [H2O] omitted and [NH3] raised to the 6th power ✓
Units mol⁻⁶ dm¹⁸ ✓
Examiner commentary: AO1/AO2. The syllabus explicitly says [H2O] is not included; candidates who divide by [H2O]6 lose both marks because the units then change to mol⁻¹² dm³⁶.
Question 3Core[3 marks]
Q (3 marks). Explain, using an equation, why the concentration of water is not included in the Kstab expression for the formation of a complex in aqueous solution.
Illustrate your answer with the ligand-exchange reaction of [Cu(H2O)6]2+ with excess concentrated hydrochloric acid.
Model answer
In dilute aqueous solution water is present in enormous excess (∼55 mol dm⁻³) compared with the complex and the ligands (typically 10⁻¹ mol dm⁻³ or less). Its concentration is therefore essentially constant during the equilibrium, so it is absorbed into the equilibrium constant and does not appear in the Kstab expression.
Water is present in large excess / its concentration is (effectively) constant ✓
Correct balanced equation for the ligand exchange with Cl⁻ ✓
Correct Kstab expression with no water term ✓
Examiner commentary: AO1/AO2. The 'large excess/constant' explanation is the syllabus-specified reason. Candidates who write ' [H2O] = 1 because water is the solvent' get the correct outcome but for the wrong reason — the marker often still awards this, but a numerical or 'large excess' justification is safer.
Question 4Extended[4 marks]
Q (4 marks). A student adds excess Na₂EDTA(aq) to a deep-blue solution of [Cu(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+.
(a) Predict, giving a reason based on the Kstab values, whether ligand exchange takes place. (2)
(b) Write an equation for the reaction and state the colour change. (2)
Model answer
(a) Kstab for the [Cu(EDTA)]²⁻ complex is about 5×105 times larger than for the ammine complex, so the equilibrium lies far in the direction of the EDTA complex — ligand exchange takes place.
Ligand exchange takes place / EDTA displaces NH₃ ✓
Reason quantified in terms of Kstab (EDTA's is ∼105 larger, or 'much larger by orders of magnitude') ✓
Balanced ionic equation with 4NH₃ and 2H₂O on the right ✓
Deep blue → pale blue ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2 — applying Kstab comparison to a new pair. Weak candidates just state 'EDTA is stronger'; markers look for a numerical or 'much larger' justification linked to the value on the paper.
Question 5Extended[5 marks]
Q (5 marks). The stability constant of [Cu(EDTA)]2− (6.3×1018 mol⁻¹ dm³) is many orders of magnitude larger than that of [Cu(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+ (1.3×1013 mol⁻⁴ dm¹²), even though the two complexes both contain four Cu–N bonds and (for EDTA) two Cu–O bonds of comparable strength.
Explain, in terms of ΔH, ΔS and ΔG, why Kstab for the EDTA complex is so much larger. This effect is known as the chelate effect.
Model answer
Compare the two ligand-exchange reactions starting from the hexa-aqua complex:
[Cu(H2O)6]2++4NH3→[Cu(NH3)4(H2O)2]2++4H2O
[Cu(H2O)6]2++EDTA4−→[Cu(EDTA)]2−+6H2O
Both reactions involve replacing Cu–O bonds by Cu–N (and Cu–O) bonds of similar strength, so ΔH is very similar in the two cases.
Counting particles in solution, however, the ammonia reaction has 5 particles on each side (net change ≈ 0), while the EDTA reaction has 2 particles on the left and 7 on the right (net change = +5 particles).
The EDTA reaction therefore has a much larger, more positive ΔS. Because ΔG=ΔH−TΔS, with similar ΔH but a much more positive TΔS, ΔG for the EDTA reaction is much more negative. Since ΔG⊖=−RTlnK, a much more negative ΔG⊖ gives a much larger Kstab — this is the chelate effect.
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (5 marks):
Similar ΔH because similar bonds are made and broken ✓
Net gain in the number of particles in solution when a polydentate ligand replaces several monodentate ones ✓
Therefore much more positive ΔS for the EDTA reaction ✓
Link to ΔG=ΔH−TΔS — ΔG more negative ✓
Link ΔG⊖=−RTlnK — larger Kstab ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2. The chelate effect must be argued through entropy — 'chelate rings are stronger' is not the syllabus answer and loses marks. The particle-count line is the key idea.
Question 6Extended[6 marks]
Q (6 marks). A sample of aqueous [Cu(EDTA)]2− contains 0.020 mol dm⁻³ of the complex and 1.0 × 10⁻³ mol dm⁻³ of free EDTA4− at equilibrium. Take Kstab([Cu(EDTA)]2−)=6.3×1018 mol⁻¹ dm³.
(a) Write the Kstab expression. (1)
(b) Rearrange it and hence calculate the concentration of free Cu2+(aq) in the solution. Give the answer to 2 significant figures with correct units. (3)
(c) Comment on the significance of the value you obtained. (2)
(c) The free-Cu²⁺ concentration is vanishingly small: essentially all of the copper in solution is present as the EDTA complex. This explains why EDTA can be used to 'lock away' toxic Cu²⁺ (e.g. as an antidote in copper poisoning, or as a preservative in shampoos and foods to prevent Cu²⁺-catalysed oxidation).
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (6 marks):
Correct expression (no water term, no ligand power greater than 1) ✓
Correct rearrangement ✓
Correct substitution using the given [complex] and [EDTA⁴⁻] ✓
Correct final value 3.2 × 10⁻¹⁸ mol dm⁻³ (units and s.f.) ✓
Free [Cu²⁺] is essentially zero / negligible ✓
Meaningful comment, e.g. explains chelation therapy / preservative use ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2/AO3. Full marks need the answer and an interpretation — Paper 4 often asks candidates to reason about the meaning of a number, not just calculate it.
Question 7Extended[7 marks]
Q (7 marks). Two silver complexes have the following stability constants at 298 K:
[Ag(NH3)2]+: Kstab=1.7×107
[Ag(CN)2]−: Kstab=5.0×1018
(a) State the units of Kstab that both complexes share, and justify your answer. (2)
(b) Deduce which of the two ligands binds Ag⁺ more strongly. (1)
(c) 0.10 mol of solid KCN is added to 1.00 dm³ of a solution originally containing 0.10 mol dm⁻³ [Ag(NH3)2]+ and 0.20 mol dm⁻³ free NH₃. Write an equation for the reaction that takes place and calculate the value of the equilibrium constant K for it. (4)
Model answer
(a) Both complexes have one metal ion and two ligand particles in the formation equation (Ag++2L→[AgL2]n). Denominator concentrations therefore have overall power 1+2=3, so units of Kstab are (mol dm−3)−2 = mol⁻² dm⁶.
(b) CN⁻ binds more strongly — Kstab([Ag(CN)2]−) is about 3×1011 times larger.
(c) [Ag(NH3)2]++2CN−→[Ag(CN)2]−+2NH3
The equilibrium constant for this ligand-exchange reaction is the ratio of the two Kstab values (numerator is the new complex, denominator the old one):
K=Kstab([Ag(NH3)2]+)Kstab([Ag(CN)2]−)=1.7×1075.0×1018=2.9×1011 (dimensionless — same units in both Kstab).
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (7 marks):
Units mol⁻² dm⁶ ✓
Justification using Ag++2L (two ligand particles) ✓
CN⁻ binds more strongly ✓
Balanced equation, 2 CN⁻ in and 2 NH₃ out ✓
Statement that K is the ratio of the two Kstab values ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2/AO3. Combining Kstab values by division is exactly the trick Paper 4 uses to show that a large exchange K can arise from a large ratio of Kstab values. Note that the units cancel because both Kstab have the same units — this is why the ratio is dimensionless.
Question 8Challenge[8 marks]
Q (8 marks). 100 cm³ of 0.20 mol dm⁻³ AgNO₃(aq) is added to 100 cm³ of 4.0 mol dm⁻³ NH₃(aq).
(c) The mixture is colourless. Ag⁺ has a d¹⁰ configuration — no partially filled d sub-shell — so neither the aqua ion nor the diammine complex absorbs visible light.
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (8 marks):
(a) Moles of Ag⁺ and NH₃ correct + total volume 0.200 dm³ ✓
(b) [NH₃]² = 3.24 (or the correct number substituted) ✓
(b) 1.8 × 10⁻⁹ mol dm⁻³ ✓
(c) Colourless ✓
(c) Correct reason: Ag⁺ is d¹⁰ / no partially filled d sub-shell / no d–d transition ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2/AO3. The link between colour and d-electron configuration is a synoptic pull from Topic 28.3 — Ag⁺ (and Zn²⁺, Cu⁺) all give colourless complexes for this reason. A well-organised solution keeps unrounded values in the calculator all the way to the final line.
Question 9Challenge[9 marks]
Q (9 marks). A student plans to determine Kstab for the copper–ammonia complex
using a colorimeter (the deep-blue complex absorbs red light strongly; the pale-blue aqua complex absorbs it only weakly).
Write a Paper 5 plan that would allow Kstab to be determined. Your plan should include:
the independent, dependent and controlled variables
how a calibration curve is prepared and used
how the equilibrium concentrations of the complex, of free Cu²⁺(aq) and of free NH₃(aq) are obtained from the data
how Kstab is then calculated, with units.
Model answer
Variables. Independent: initial [NH₃] added to a fixed [Cu²⁺]. Dependent: absorbance at a chosen wavelength in the red (e.g. 610 nm). Controlled: temperature (thermostat, e.g. 298 K), the total volume of the mixture (make up to a fixed mark), path length (same cuvette), the initial [Cu²⁺], the wavelength, and the ionic strength (constant background electrolyte).
Calibration. Prepare a series of solutions with a known concentration of [Cu(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+ by mixing a fixed [Cu²⁺] with a very large excess of NH₃ so that essentially all the Cu is complexed. Measure the absorbance of each at 610 nm and plot absorbance against [complex] — a straight line through the origin (Beer–Lambert law).
Experimental runs. Mix known volumes of standard Cu(II) sulfate solution and standard NH₃(aq) so that a series of mixtures has the same total [Cu] but varying [NH₃] (not a large excess). Make each up to the same volume, thermostat, and measure the absorbance at 610 nm.
Analysis. Read [complex]eq from the calibration line for each mixture. Free [Cu²⁺] = (total Cu) − [complex]. Free [NH₃] = (total NH₃) − 4 × [complex]. Substitute into
Kstab=[Cu2+][NH3]4[[Cu(NH3)4(H2O)2]2+]
and calculate Kstab for each run. Units: mol⁻⁴ dm¹². Average the values and report a single result with a spread; consistency across runs at different [NH₃] is evidence that the method is sound.
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (9 marks):
Variables: correct independent and dependent ✓
At least two relevant controls (temperature, wavelength, path length, total volume, ionic strength) ✓
Calibration: prepare standards of the complex by using a large excess of NH₃ ✓
Plot absorbance vs [complex]; straight line, uses Beer–Lambert ✓
Experimental runs: fix [Cu] total, vary [NH₃] to non-excess values, same volume ✓
[complex] read from the calibration line ✓
[Cu²⁺] = total Cu − [complex] ✓
[NH₃]free = total NH₃ − 4 × [complex] ✓
Correct Kstab expression, units mol⁻⁴ dm¹², and averaging (or repeats/comment on precision) ✓
Examiner commentary: AO3. Paper 5 marks reward reasoned controls and derived concentrations. The mass-balance step (subtracting the complexed Cu and NH₃ from the totals) is where most candidates lose marks by writing 'take the initial concentrations' instead.
Question 10Challenge[10 marks]
Q (10 marks). This question is about the equilibrium
(a) State the meaning of Kstab and explain, using the units, why the exponent of [SCN−] in the expression is 1 rather than 6. (2)
(b) 0.0050 mol dm⁻³ Fe(NO₃)₃(aq) is mixed with an equal volume of 0.0050 mol dm⁻³ KSCN(aq). Set up and solve a quadratic to find the equilibrium concentration of [Fe(SCN)]2+. (5)
(c) A student then adds a small amount of solid NaF to the equilibrium mixture. The colour fades sharply. Suggest, in terms of Kstab, what is happening. (Kstab([FeF6]3−)≈1015 mol⁻⁶ dm¹⁸.) (2)
(d) Justify quantitatively why doubling the temperature would not necessarily double Kstab. (1)
Model answer
(a) Kstab is the equilibrium constant for the formation of [Fe(SCN)]2+ from its constituent ions in water. The units mol⁻¹ dm³ correspond to (mol dm⁻³)⁻¹, so the total order in the denominator is 1+1=2 and only one SCN⁻ enters the complex; the exponent of [SCN−] is therefore 1.
(b) After mixing, both [Fe³⁺] and [SCN⁻] are halved to 0.00250 mol dm⁻³. Let x = equilibrium [Fe(SCN)]2+.
(Physical check: x<0.00250.) So [Fe(SCN)]2+ = 1.3 × 10⁻³ mol dm⁻³ at equilibrium; about 52 % of the iron is complexed.
(c) Fluoride has a very large Kstab with Fe³⁺ (∼1015 mol⁻⁶ dm¹⁸, about 1012 times larger than SCN⁻'s), so F⁻ ligand-exchanges the SCN⁻ out of the complex:
[Fe(SCN)]2++6F−→[FeF6]3−+SCN−
The deep-red [Fe(SCN)]2+ concentration falls to nearly zero, so the red colour fades.
(d) Kstab has an exponential temperature dependence via lnK=−ΔH⊖/(RT)+ΔS⊖/R; because T appears in the denominator of an exponential term, K does not scale linearly with T.
Why this scores
Mark-by-mark breakdown (10 marks):
(a) Kstab definition ✓
(a) 'Units mol⁻¹ dm³ → one ligand particle' argument ✓
(b) Kstab expression and correct quadratic set-up ✓
(b) Discriminant and (or clear correct algebra) ✓
(b) Valid root chosen (x<0.00250) ✓
(b) [complex] = 1.3 × 10⁻³ mol dm⁻³ ✓
(c) F⁻ has much larger Kstab / displaces SCN⁻ ✓
(c) Equation with [FeF6]3− ✓
(d) Non-linear (exponential) T-dependence of K — Gibbs / van 't Hoff style argument ✓
Examiner commentary: AO2/AO3. A ten-mark synoptic question links reasoning about units, an ICE quadratic and a qualitative ligand-exchange prediction. The most common lapse in part (b) is to forget the halving of the concentrations when equal volumes are mixed; that alone would give an answer twice as large.
These model answers are written by Tutopiya to cover the same syllabus content as the official Cambridge International AS & A Level 9701 specification (2025-2027), using the same command words and mark allocations as the exam. They are exam-style questions, not reproductions of past paper questions.